Who's gonna win ROY

[jaybird_1981]

He was at 3.3-something when I made the post. Furthermore, what other AL rookie is more deserving than a guy that has gone 29/32 in saves on one of the better teams in the AL?

I would take an everyday player over a closer if it was comparable and it is pretty close right now.

[gladdyontherise]

I would take an everyday player over a closer if it was comparable and it is pretty close right now.

I'd suprisingly disagree, you cant undervalue a good closer, and 29 for 32 is pretty solid

[jaybird_1981]

I'd suprisingly disagree, you cant undervalue a good closer, and 29 for 32 is pretty solid

I think closers are the most overrated commodity in baseball. Feliz only has an ERA+ of 118 which is pretty low for a closer. Jonny Venters in the NL has a 378 ERA+ for comparison and no one mentions him.

[pootshwan]

I think closers are the most overrated commodity in baseball.

Agreed....Also most overpaid IMO.