Friendly Debate

[WVcoltsfan]

First off this thread is just for fun, I was having a friendly debate with my buddy Jason (jdio13) on here about who was better, Brady or Manning. So it got me to thinking and figured Id throw it up here. Which card would you rather have for your PC?

Tom Brady 2008 Bowman Sterling Patch Auto /20



OR

Peyton Manning 2008 SP Authentic Retro Rookie Jersey Auto /75



Again, this is just a friendly debate so make your pick and let us know why!!

P.S. Dont pay attention to the fact that he has access to a scanner (lol)

Thanks everyone!

[tylermckinzie]

Well, let me state two different opinions.

If it's by the card, I want the Brady. The Peyton is very nice, but you can find nice Peyton autos somewhat affordable if you are patient. Brady autos are never cheap, and nice ones (such as patches) are always quite high. Supply and demand.

If it's by the QB- I don't think there's been a better QB than Manning. I don't judge just on the basis of rings. I just think he's been as cerebral and as tough to defend as any QB in history. He's been the constant on a team that has changed around him, yet every year the Colts are in the hunt. You can't prove it using stats and you can't convince me I am wrong.... nor can I convince anyone else I'm right. You just go with what you think, and trust me, I am not a Colts fan.

[jaybird_1981]

The Manning.

[Porbeagle]

Well, the Manning looks much better and the auto is on card which is a big plus. But being a Michigan fan and since I'm convinced that Brady is the better QB I'd prefere his card.

[rjcla30]

I would take the On card auto of Manning - it's a very nice card.

[rickysigai]

i would take the brady - just becouse manning has thousands of autos out there

[27tinman]

I'd take the Brady. Like stated above-there are a lot more Manning autos out there than Brady autos, and Brady autos are more valuable. I don't really collect either player, so value would be the main consideration for me.

[pander69]

I would have to go with the Brady for pretty much the same reasons as 27Tinman. I think Manning is the better QB, but for me, it would be the value of the Brady.

[thedynasty141]

Thats like asking if the sky is blue. Brady DUHHH

[hazeofgreen]

Brady :D