Friendly Debate

[OZTATAR]

The Brady. For 3 reasons:

1. I personally think Brady is the better QB
2. Though the Maniing card design is nice, I like the Bowman's Best design better
3. The Brady has a better patch

[bangsportscards]

I like the Bowman Sterling product better so based on that I'd take the Brady.

I want compare QB vs. QB as they both are great. Each has their own unique pluses, let's say that!

Brian

[Titantron]

Brady. No contest. Its worth 3 times as much. Manning is a nice guy and signs more than anyone. brady autos are hard to come by. It has nothing to do with who is better. Manning is obviously better, but this is simple economics. Sell the brady and buy 3 or 4 nice manning Autos.

BTW. I had that same manning card. Wish i still had it based on some of the answers here.

[Project 4]

Brady is the better QB IMO. You play to win the game not to have the best stats. Manning is no slouch but if you are able to lead your team to 3 Superbowl victories that should be the utmost importance. It's not like Brady was Trent Dilfer, riding on the coattails of the defense. He was a major contributor to those SB teams. I know the argument can be made that Peyton did not have the teams that Brady had but it is what it is and we can never know for sure. If Peyton wins 2 more SB's and tie with Brady than hands down Manning.

With that said if it's for PC I assume we would not sell or trade it so I would rather have the Peyton card because it is an "on auto" card. I could care less about value since it would be PC and both these players are both HOF bound.

[jaybird_1981]

Brady. No contest. Its worth 3 times as much. Manning is a nice guy and signs more than anyone. brady autos are hard to come by. It has nothing to do with who is better. Manning is obviously better, but this is simple economics. Sell the brady and buy 3 or 4 nice manning Autos.

BTW. I had that same manning card. Wish i still had it based on some of the answers here.

The question was "Which card would you rather have for your PC". Not which one will sell for more, so that could be the reasoning to some of the answers.

[BradWells1977]

Personally I would take the Manning....I love on card autos....nice auto too...not the scribbly one of Brady.......but for resale purposes I would take the Brady...

[Titantron]

The question was "Which card would you rather have for your PC". Not which one will sell for more, so that could be the reasoning to some of the answers.

right, but most people like me would be 10 times more likely to allready have a manning auto in thier pc, but no brady because of the price. Therefore I'd rather have the brady, but it may have been the manning if i didnt allready have one.

[WVcoltsfan]

yea guys, im not really trying to start the manning v brady whose better argument...just which card would you rather have in the PC...

I get the brady arguments...Im just a manning guy...lol