is this a fair replacement ?

**klavalla** · 10-24-2013, 09:37 PM

I redeemed a ovechkin panini prime autos auto xx/99 was replaced with a nugent titanium reserve auto no numbered I dont have a beckett and there's no sales that I saw on fleabay any help I know nuge is good but is it ovech trade out good ?? Thanks a million
Phil

**87sluggo** · 10-24-2013, 10:08 PM

Hiya Phil! Is it an 11/12 Titanium Reserve auto? Cuz that's worth a fair bit BV...........personally I'd rather have the Ovi if it was a keeper, but you'd probably be able to flip the RNH just as easily.........Oilers fans are suckers hahahaaaa!!! No offense to Oilers fans. What? Too late? Oh well..........

**theboxbreaker96** · 10-24-2013, 10:08 PM

I would not be real happy with that. On Card Auto of a superstar /99 replaced with a Sticker Auto of Unproven #1 Pick non numbered is not fair to me.

The Hopkins may be SPed though. Is this the card you received? http://www.ebay.com/itm/11-12-panini...item35cd390f79

If so I would think it would sell around $35 Ovechkin Prime Signatures $50

**klavalla** · 10-24-2013, 10:12 PM

Yeah they sent it today ....2011 Panini Titanium (11-12)
Titanium Reserve Autographs

**canucksfan007** · 10-24-2013, 10:13 PM

Id take that replacement. Those Prime Autos may be hard signed ..... but that have got to be the worst autos to come out in some time ( assuming this is last years Prime ). The pens they issued to the players to use for the autos did not work with the type of gloss finish on the card. This resulted in smudging / bubbling / generally just really ugly autographed cards.

Not to mention, the RNH auto is a rookie year auto .... where the AO is just another low end AO auto

**klavalla** · 10-24-2013, 10:54 PM

Cool thanks for the help peeps. Wasnt sure been out of the card area this year and wasn't sure I know I got a heck of a box of the prime and the alex was the worst card in the box lol yeah that good. Lol ang ways thanks all
Phil

**jmatchett** · 10-25-2013, 04:49 PM

Originally Posted by klavalla View Post

I redeemed a ovechkin panini prime autos auto xx/99 was replaced with a nugent titanium reserve auto no numbered I dont have a beckett and there's no sales that I saw on fleabay any help I know nuge is good but is it ovech trade out good ?? Thanks a million
Phil

Which one do you think fits better into your collection?

**MR.M's Cards** · 10-25-2013, 07:11 PM

panini is notoriously brutal with there replacements there entire redemption program is a joke

**RGM81** · 10-25-2013, 07:14 PM

I'd call it a wash. Ovechkin's market has dropped off quite a bit in the past couple years. RNH still has a lot to prove to live up the #1 pick hype, but in the long run it's a top tier auto for another top-tier auto. Too bad it drops off from hard-signed to sticker, though.