kidd or payton

[YankeePride]

I keep reading about Payton's defense ... what about Kidds? He is All-Defensive, and his D on the final shot vs. Detroit in Game 2 sums it all up.
And as for Payton's scoring - teams with scoring point guards don't win championships. When was the last time that happened? It might happen this year with Tony Parker, but I wouldn't exactly call him a true scorer yet.

[cardtrader]

kidd is much better

[reezy]

Kidd ...i can't name 5 players i'd rather have on me team than jason kidd...just my opinion

[mjblaze]

If they were the same age, I'd take Payton. They're not, so I'll take Kidd.

[AlwaysaBucksFan]

I'd take Kidd also. He's good all the way around. Maybe Payton was better in his younger years but I didn't know much about him then. If we are talking now, Kidd wins hands down. Payton has a tuff time making a lay up these days and doesn't know when to shut up. I hope he does go to LA. We got Desmond Mason and he was the TRUE deal in that trade!