When I got my damaged Price card, I literally kept the card (along with the other cards that it came with, because I wanted to show them how the other 3 cards were in great shape) in the foil wrapper and placed it back in the UD Ultimate Collection box and mailed it back in a padded envelope. Obviously the other 3 cards meant nothing to me, so I was able to make my point without losing anything of value over it. I insured the card when I sent it, but didn't use delivery confirmation. Hope this helps !