TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25


    First name:    Last name:    Sport:    

Peyton Manning Addresses Report   Sport: Football

Player overall success: 59%



Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 61%    
Total number of submission on this address: 384
# of Success: 215  # of Failed: 136  # of Pending: 33
Instruction:Send a small donation for his charity.
Added by:Cmwill24   Added on: 05-28-2009
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
CoachAHess 06-20-202507-02-2025Failure 121/1No forwarding address 
JDrake 05-20-202506-02-2025Failure 131/1RTS No forwarding address 
griffjeremy2212 02-23-202407-11-2024Failure 1382/0Return to sender, no forward address 
Robert9312 08-01-202309-28-2023Failure 581/0RTS address blacked out 
jpollard 06-27-202307-27-2023Failure 301/0'99 Pacific; RTS, crossed out address... :( 
bboonie53 02-21-202303-07-2023Failure 141/02000 Topps/RTS 
bboonie53 02-21-202303-14-2023Failure 201/02000 Score/RTS 
Cowboysfan04 12-12-202212-27-2022Failure 152/0$10 donation RTS 
krazykid112 12-08-202201-09-2023Failure 322/0sent two cards return to sender 
LarkinsTTM 11-30-202204-06-2023Failure 1261/01 Cards and $10 donation/RTS 
devindavis 09-02-202211-16-2022Success 751/1Sent $15 donation and trading card. Luckily I got it back signed today, super excited about this one! 
Rocky20 10-02-202110-26-2021Failure 241/1Return to sender Not Deliverable to address. 
Garski26 08-30-202109-13-2021Failure 141/1RTS, hoping to find a better address and try again 
mtool 07-11-202107-24-2021Failure 131/0return to sender 
JPSD16 05-28-202107-03-2021Failure 361/0RTS 
Ckbrown81 05-27-202106-14-2021Success 182/1Sent 2 got 1 signed 
pmc14 04-20-202108-02-2021Failure 1041/0RTS 
jdresbach 04-20-202105-10-2021Failure 201/1card and $20/RTS 
RCSDTTMer 04-14-202105-27-2021Failure 432/0RTS don't use address 
Esmith22collector 03-18-2021 Failure -1/0RTS 
recbball 02-22-202103-13-2021Success 191/1Sent LOR, SASE, 1 card. Received signed card.
BayAreaJavy 02-13-202103-19-2021Success 331/1  
pancake513 01-23-2021 Pending -3/0Sent 3 cards and 5 bucks 
Wellsalex18 01-11-2021 Pending -1/0$10 donation 
jeff1981ny 01-07-2021 Pending -1/01 Mossic 
schrums1 08-25-202009-09-2020Failure 151/1Sent 1 card, note, $10 and SASE. Return to Sender. 
FlyOrDieGuy1992 08-01-202008-13-2020Failure 121/1UTF 
JPSD16 07-24-202008-25-2020Failure 322/02 cards, LOR, SASE/ RTS. NO LONGER AT LOCATION. DO NOT SEND HERE. 
BayAreaJavy 06-24-202006-30-2021Failure 3711/01 card and donation/ RTS 
marty77 05-31-202007-17-2020Success 471/1Sent own pic 
jeff1981ny 04-21-2020 Pending -2/0  
TheCajunCollected 04-16-202004-29-2020Failure 132/2rts 
tster24 04-01-202004-09-2020Success 85/1  
bobby1134 02-28-201903-14-2019Failure 131/0RTS 
PokeyTheBrave 02-22-2019 Failure -1/0Sent 1 playing card - giving up. Got autograph through Colorado address. 
pokemonclub 02-11-201903-01-2019Failure 181/0RTS again 
pmc14 02-04-201902-22-2019Failure 181/0RTS UTF 
JayHo7284 02-02-201902-13-2019Failure 111/0RTS - Unclaimed 
SpeshD74 01-28-201902-22-2019Failure 251/1Sent 8x10 and money-order donation (Money-Order was cashed and photo was returned unsigned (2 try) 
Ozconnergoheels 01-27-201902-11-2019Failure 151/0Rts 
pokemonclub 01-19-201902-09-2019Failure 211/0RTS 
moneygold1264 01-16-201902-01-2019Success 162/2  
walls1387 01-15-201901-23-2019Failure 81/1Sent 1 card and $10-rts 
Aherekar86 01-05-2019 Pending -2/0Sent 2 card and a donation 
Jim182 12-28-201801-19-2019Success 221/0Sent LOR, SASE, an 8x10 and a donation. He sent my picture back and sent a signed 8.5x11 
Craiggb 10-15-201811-05-2018Success 211/1  
Zrianna08 09-20-201810-06-2018Failure 162/0  
StarrsCards 09-02-201810-09-2018Failure 371/1RTS 
Ky1603 08-29-201810-13-2018Success 451/12013 Presige - $20 
dish142002 07-28-2018 Failure -1/0RTS 
dish142002 07-17-2018 Failure -1/0rts 
dmule2413 07-05-2018 Pending -2/0Donated 20 dollars 
peteyland 07-03-201808-17-2018Failure 451/0RTS - sent a picture and donation to his foundation 
troyjk 06-05-201810-19-2018Success 1361/1Sent one card, LOR, and SASE. 
Tbird21 05-12-201806-09-2018Success 281/1sase with 2 cards and $10 :) comeon big money.... sent to CO addy only sent one back signed. ig 10$ per. seemed like he put it back in the sleeve too fast too 
chicagobullsjoe 05-05-201805-12-2018Failure 71/0RTS 
ChristianDH21 05-05-201805-17-2018Failure 122/0sent 2 cards, LOR, and SASE. $10 donation...RTS unable to forward 
greenlion 04-23-201805-10-2018Failure 173/3RTS 
derrich1112 04-17-201805-04-2018Failure 172/0RTS cannot forward 
wolverine297 04-09-201804-20-2018Success 111/1Sent 1 card and donation. Did not sign card (maybe because it was his rookie card) but sent signed postcard 
Dee990 04-09-2018 Failure -2/0Sent 2 cards + $10 donation - RTS 
Itsthejw 04-04-201805-31-2018Success 571/0Sent 1 card, letter, SASE and $10 donation, card returned signed 
Jim182 03-16-201803-22-2018Failure 61/0Sent an 8x10 and a donation to his charity. RTS. Gonna try sending again 
aqscards 03-14-201803-30-2018Failure 162/0STated I would send a donation when my cards were returned. I still intend to. RTS 
locly 03-10-201804-06-2018Failure 261/0  
JOHNNYCISCO96 03-01-201804-13-2018Success 422/1  
Danmay55 02-28-201803-19-2018Success 181/1sent custom pic and $10 check to foundation, send back pic unsigned but sent his own card signed 
Baldones 02-28-201803-09-2018Success 91/1Sent one card and 5 more for him to keep. Signed one card mailed the rest back SASE 
Duketter 02-13-2018 Pending -2/0  
twp0906 02-10-201804-10-2018Failure 582/0  
bdmorr 02-01-201802-14-2018Failure 131/0RTS 
cutchamin 01-16-2018 Pending -1/0  
dgoode97 01-12-201801-29-2018Success 171/1Sent a Super Bowl 50 card and a donation for his charity. Got the card back signed! Awesome return! Thanks Mr. Manning! 
danob11 01-09-2018 Pending -2/0Mailed a FB card and Sport Illustrated with $20 to his foundation 
Redskins2124 01-09-201801-29-2018Success 201/1Signed one in black sharpie! 
codysmith1997 01-04-201801-19-2018Failure 151/0Sent card with LOR and $5 donation plus SASE. RTS, UTF 
BugeaterBaseball 12-28-201701-29-2018Failure 321/0Sent $10 donation for 1 Broncos card./RTS resending to CO address 
jman23 12-27-201701-11-2018Failure 151/0RTS 
Parklandball14 12-26-2017 Failure -1/0RTS 
Nlach 12-22-201709-12-2018Success 2631/1  
cutchamin 12-21-2017 Failure -1/0RTS 
TripleCrown24 12-19-201712-28-2017Failure 91/0RTS UTF 
Donhutson 12-14-201701-07-2018Failure 241/0sent $5 RTS 
Wyattket88 11-27-2017 Pending -1/0  
Logan Richmond 11-11-201712-11-2017Success 301/12013 Topps #200 and $5 
MisterE 11-10-201711-30-2017Failure 201/0R T S 
lkfojtik 10-25-201711-19-2017Success 251/1Sentence LOR, SASE, Topps mini +$5. YUGE win! 
Spikes40 10-16-201710-30-2017Failure 141/0RTS 
alex0 10-10-201710-15-2017Failure 51/0RTS never got there; didn't leave the state 
bdemerson94 09-18-2017 Pending -3/0Sent 3 Colts Cards. 
Donhutson 08-17-201710-16-2017Failure 601/0unsigned 
caitlynnwood16 08-09-201709-25-2017Success 471/1$5. Signed but little bent not bad 
username53 08-05-201709-05-2017Failure 311/0Sent $20 donation and mini helmet. Got helmet back unsigned. :( 
Revelation 08-02-201708-17-2017Success 152/1Sent my two pocket helmets back unsigned, and sent me his standard signed photo. Authentic not a pre-print.
MitchUKTTM 07-27-201708-24-2017Success 281/1Sent x1 card and SASE. Included $5 donation to PeyBack Foundation. - Returned today! Thank you Mr Manning!
flutie13 06-10-201707-22-2017Success 421/1Awesome success. Sent $5 
marty77 05-31-201706-24-2017Failure 241/0Returned cards unsigned 
jwongnyy 05-17-201706-12-2017Failure 262/0Sent 2 4x6: RTS 
Thepatman1985 05-11-201706-06-2017Success 261/1Sent a 8x10 recieved my photo back they sent another 8x10 photo with his signature on it question Real or Auto Pen but its something. 
bucsboy 05-09-201705-18-2017Success 91/1Received a 3x5 photo instead of my custom index card. Was really hoping to add the custom to a project I'm working on, but I'm very grateful to get anything back signed either way. $5 donation. 
Bacon 04-15-201705-22-2017Success 371/1Sent 2016 Card, LOR, SASE. Card returned signed in black sharpie! (Send date is an estimate) 
acemaker 04-03-201705-22-2017Success 492/1Signed my '99 Finest and didn't sign my '99 Score. Sent $10.00 Donation. 
Royals1982 03-31-201705-15-2017Success 451/1signed 1 card with $5 donation. Looks very real compared to my Topps cert card. 
card openings 03-06-201705-15-2017Success 691/1Sent a $5 donation and my 2014 score came back beautifully signed 
locly 03-01-201704-04-2017Success 331/1  
DirtyDunnTTMs 02-27-201704-15-2017Success 461/1Sweet return 
IsaiahZEAH14 02-26-2017 Pending -3/0  
jacobgallipeau 02-23-2017 Pending -2/0included $10 donation 
Calebssportscards 02-16-201703-25-2017Success 361/1Sent a card and $5 cash// Yes! and he even signed my card, I was just hoping for a pre-signed card 
Ngc1001 01-25-201702-18-2017Success 241/1Recieved my jersey and donation back but recieved a signed 8x10 
jg0516 01-05-2017 Pending -1/01 Jersey 
alabamagator925 01-04-201703-04-2017Success 592/1Sent $10. Received Broncos card signed in blue, Colts card unsigned. Amazing success! 
footballautos 01-01-201701-01-2017Success 01/1Dates incorrect, logging old successes 
diback34 11-28-201612-16-2016Failure 181/0  
remkits 09-16-201609-23-2016Failure 71/0Received Pre Print back (date sent is an estimate) 
JayHo7284 04-27-201605-07-2016Failure 103/0  
FootballBob 01-22-201602-12-2016Success 211/1Sent one card and $10 donation check 
Bsn8810500 12-09-201512-18-2015Failure 91/1sent $10 donation, a card, and my card, check, and preprinted signature on his picture were all returned.
nickschulz123 08-05-2015 Pending -3/0  
SyxxSynse 05-04-201505-25-2015Failure 212/0Sent two cards with $20 donation. Returned cards and check, and sent two pre-prints. 
DMackie 04-09-2015 Pending -1/0Sent Colts mini helmet with a donation to his charity 
Jlack 02-20-201503-12-2015Failure 192/0Returned the 2 cards and sent a pre-print autographed wallet picture. Very disappointed. 
Raiderprty 08-09-201408-18-2014Failure 91/0sent back card unsigned along with preprint. success? ehhhh, sure? 
yankees02 06-20-201407-05-2014Failure 150/0Preprint 
gottahaveautos451 06-09-201406-18-2014Success 91/0same preprint as arinesmith reported. sent my card back, unsigned. 
SammyD619 05-31-201406-10-2014Failure 101/1pre print 
Csmith3 04-20-201401-01-2015Failure 2561/0Sent card back unsigned along with a PP 
Chipscards01 04-15-201404-23-2014Success 81/2I guess u could consider this a success. I sent a pre sign card photobucket and the card i sent. Thanks. 
prezby97 02-10-201402-13-2014Success 31/0Received the same pre-print shown in the last success. 
arinesmith 01-24-2014 Failure -1/0Sent 2013 Topps Card and $5 cash 
arinesmith 01-14-201401-31-2014Success 170/1Sent email and got PP. Something for nothing.
PaulsTTM 01-01-201406-25-2014Success 1741/1Personalised 
chitownautos 12-15-201301-02-2014Success 180/14x6 Pre-Print Autographed Photo...18 Days 
chefsanders 12-10-201301-02-2014Failure 231/1Preprint card 
packers1287 11-04-201311-10-2013Failure 60/1Pre Print 
sportshunter73 10-07-201312-17-2013Failure 711/0Sent 8x10 Sports illustrated, SASE and letter. Hope it comes back after he just won the game!. Just received, preprint, kept my sharpie :( 
dscards 10-01-2013 Pending -1/0Sent 8x10 with donation. Fingers crossed I don't get the preprint. 
cy young 09-27-201310-12-2013Failure 151/0rookie and stars longevity#3.GOT HTE USUAL PREPRINT NO SIGNED CARD 
cy young 09-24-201310-03-2013Failure 91/0second attempt #2 hope to get this back. he didnt sign it and sent a preprint back 
cy young 09-24-201310-04-2013Failure 101/0he better send this back signed.cant believe it returned unsigned. 
marty77 09-21-201305-07-2014Failure 2282/0  
TheAutographKid6 08-22-201309-14-2013Success 231/1Didnt think this one was gunna come back but it did signed best ttm ever. 
dawgbizkit83 04-01-201304-08-2013Failure 71/0McFarlane Base + $10 donation, did not sign mcfarlane base, kept the money, sent a Broncos 5x7 autoed photo that is a little smudged, not quite a success 
chefsanders 03-28-201304-08-2013Failure 111/08x10 and $5. Kept my money and sent preprint 
chitownip13 02-27-201303-30-2013Success 301/1Signed Broncos 8-10. Hell of a success from a even better QB 
GoWarrior 02-27-201303-08-2013Failure 91/0One card and check for $5. Sent my check back and card unsigned along with a preprint card. 
cava11aro 10-11-201210-22-2012Failure 111/0sent 8x10 and 5$ donation. Hopefully it reaches him in Denver somehow....returned donation and photo unsigned...sent me a preprint 
BRevere11 08-07-201208-16-2012Success 93/0Pre-Print 
Huntman84 08-04-201208-05-2012Pending 11/0  
biggsy2323 08-01-201208-08-2012Failure 70/1Partial success, sent email.. Got a preprinted wallet size photo 
Coltron57 07-24-201207-29-2012Pending 52/0Sent 1999 Bowman and Topps Breast Cancer base. W/ $5 donation. 
mnautosttm 07-08-201207-23-2012Success 151/12nd time, this time sent a RC and $5. Got back SIGNED!!!!! Sadly, it was slightly damaged. But gr8 success 
Thefon19 06-28-201207-23-2012Success 251/1After getting a preprint, I sent an another card with a 5 dollar cash donation hoping to receive an autograph on my card and not another preprint! Got it back signed and took my 5 dollar donation 
Thefon19 06-11-201206-23-2012Failure 121/0Sent letter along with trading card. Received a Pre Print. 
Thefon19 06-10-201206-23-2012Failure 131/0Trading Card. Got back a Pre Print. He is in Denver so I don't think he has a lot of opportunity to sign from the Foundation. 
JayHo7284 05-16-201206-15-2012Failure 302/0Got crappy 8x10 
JayHo7284 05-11-201205-17-2012Failure 61/0Got signed 8x10, but sent back my license plate unsigned...😖 
JayHo7284 05-11-201206-01-2012Failure 211/0Think the Manning Autograph Train might have departed...for now 
SoccerSwag23 05-07-201205-17-2012Success 101/2Pre-Print, But I didn't send a donation and it's better than nothing. 
Lapo0013 04-06-201206-08-2012Success 631/1Hope I get this, sent jersey card and a 5 dollar donation. Sent back check with pp 3x6. Sent again, got it back signed beautifully in blue!!! 
Seminole912 04-01-201204-22-2012Failure 211/0Pp card 
xtra-innings 02-29-201204-13-2012Success 431/110 for 10 in last 2 yrs!!! Sent $5 donation.
batwars67 02-28-201203-03-2012Failure 41/0COME ON PEYTON STUPID PP CARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 
RichSlyFox14 02-10-2012 Pending -1/0could be bad timing but still hoping for the best! sent RC & $10 donation 
Petez_BB 02-08-201202-23-2012Failure 151/0SENT BASEBALL AND DONATION 
bball15fan 02-01-201202-18-2012Failure 171/0sent mini helmet and 20 bucks... recieved picture and unsigned mini...and took my 20 dollars!! This is my 6th try still nothing to show 
johnweb83 02-01-201202-12-2012Success 111/1Returned SI unsigned but did send a signed 8x10. Sig is sightly different from others I've seen returned this week so I have a good feeling about it. 
JayHo7284 01-30-201202-16-2012Failure 171/1Sent signed 8x10 (not pp), but didn't sign the license plate I sent. 
#1BRONCSFAN 01-27-201205-07-2012Success 1001/1Signed my MVP Upper Deck card in blue sharpie. Very happy cause he plays for by Broncos now!!! 
sfirtel 01-23-201202-09-2012Failure 171/0My 6 year old son sent him a hand written letter with a card to sign and a $18 donation to his charity. He sent back a pre-printed card along with the check for $18 sent to him. No real signature. Despite the failure, my son will still be thrilled. 
ZG3411 01-20-2012 Pending -1/0sending a Jersey and $15. wish me luck! 
SportsFan2342 01-19-201202-10-2012Success 221/1i guess i lucked out!!! peyton signed a 4x6 photo for me, didnt send the preprint photo like he did to many others 
prezby97 01-18-201202-08-2012Failure 210/1Received 5x7 preprint card and my card back unsigned. No donation-maybe that's the key. Oh well...
realestateguy247 01-15-201202-11-2012Success 271/0sent mr manning a card for him to sign for my son. he sent the card back unsigned with an additional pre printed signed card. 
#1NFLOwner 01-15-201202-16-2012Success 321/1sent mini helmet-came back signed to me also sent $10.00 cash donation 
ddgrboy 01-10-201201-19-2012Success 92/1signed 1/2 with a donation of $20. Will try him again soon :) 
bigsportsfan1 01-10-201201-17-2012Success 71/1Signed my card in blue sharpie, thanks Peyton! 
ZG3411 01-07-201201-17-2012Success 101/1signed card in blue! 
JayHo7284 01-06-201201-25-2012Success 191/1Sent $15
kardkid 01-04-201201-17-2012Success 131/13rd manning, got this one for my bro, thanks mr manning 
bboonie53 01-04-201201-17-2012Success 132/3Offered card to him. Got 3 cards back, one was an extra. Signed the extra and one of mine. Mine got smudged but the other one was great. 
phillyboi90 01-02-201201-20-2012Pending 181/1card signed! 
harley2001 12-30-201101-12-2012Success 131/1Fast return 
emc23 12-28-201101-06-2012Failure 91/1Sent 8x10 back unsigned. Sent preprint 5x7 
lilgreg419 12-28-201101-06-2012Success 91/1Sent 3 dollars for his PeyBack Foundation. This will be my 2nd returnd of him! he is a very cool guy!!! 
coronado2010 12-27-201101-06-2012Success 101/1a little smudged, but still a great success! First return of the year!!(view all of my successes @ coronado2010ttm.blogspot.com) 
jbev44 12-22-201101-15-2012Failure 241/0Sent an 8x10 and a small donation - Got my donation and photo back along with the preprint auto 
bcommerce 12-20-201109-17-2012Failure 2711/0Writing this one Off!! 
GoWarrior 12-20-2011 Pending -1/0Trying 8x10 for second time. Got the PP last time, trying it with $5 donation. Peyton doesn't seem to be signing many 8x0s 
GoWarrior 12-20-201101-06-2012Failure 171/0Trying 8x10 again. Got PP last time. Adding $5 donation this time. Peyton doesn't seem to be signing many 8x10s, looks like cards only so we'll see. Yup, came back again unsigned with PP card. 
kardkid 12-19-201101-03-2012Success 151/1Got my 2nd manning back, inscribed his number in this card#18 1st TTM of the year! 
JayHo7284 12-17-201112-27-2011Success 101/1Another great success from Peyton. One of the best signers & players in the game!
sportsfreak10 12-17-201112-27-2011Success 102/1Sent him two cards and a $5 donation to his charity.got both cards back and one was signed perfectly 
lilgreg419 12-15-201112-23-2011Success 81/1Very nice!! Sent 1 UpperDeck Card and enclosed 5 dollars for his PeyBack Foundation
ZG3411 12-13-201112-22-2011Success 91/1Sent an 8x10 for the 4th time with $10 donation, figured I'd get it back with a PP but it came back beautify signed in blue sharpie!!!! Early Christmas gift to myself lol :)
natethebaseball 12-11-201112-23-2011Success 121/1got a picture singed then got it back 
marxcaleb 12-10-201112-19-2011Success 91/1sent a picture, and signed beutifully!!!!! 
Grant1525 12-10-201112-17-2011Success 71/1Really Fast Signer
rarehunter916 12-09-201112-17-2011Success 81/1Sent 1 card, LOR, SASE 
newbernbears 12-09-201112-19-2011Failure 101/0sent pic back unsigned, kept donation (which is fine) and sent back preprint! will try again with trading card! 
garpike 12-07-201112-16-2011Success 91/1Success #9...Got my check and AUTOGRAPHED card back 
bcommerce 12-07-201112-16-2011Success 93/1Signed a white fleer inscribed in blue sharpie added #18. Sweet Sig! Kept other two cards, fair trade to me. 
cincyarmyvet 12-07-201101-10-2012Success 341/1signed the card in blue pen!
realestateguy247 12-05-201112-20-2011Success 152/1I sent Peyton two cards for my son. He signed one and returned the other unsigned. It made my son's day! 
xtra-innings 12-02-201112-10-2011Success 81/1$5 donation enclosed
marxcaleb 12-01-201112-09-2011Success 81/1Sent an awesome card!, got it back signed!!!!! 
mwp33 11-30-201112-09-2011Failure 91/0Sent SI and $10 for charity instructing them to keep $ even if not able to sign. SI came back unsigned. Bummer. 
bounty331 11-25-201112-02-2011Success 71/1hope its real! My second success!! 
GoWarrior 11-23-201112-02-2011Failure 91/0Sent my 8x10 back unsigned and added the preprint card. Will have to try again. 
redrocker98ta 11-22-201112-02-2011Success 101/1Signed my 2011 Prestige card in blue sharpie, just awesome! Thanks Peyton 
white2128 11-21-201112-12-2011Success 211/1Signed and personalized my 8x10 of him under center during his Super Bowl win. Also signed and personalized by Saturday. New favorite success 
badgerboys2 11-16-201111-26-2011Success 101/1sent a 2009 topps but since it was too glossy, peyton sent his own 2002 UD card signed! snet $10 donation 
Csarge8 11-16-201112-05-2011Success 192/1Thanks Peyton, huge success. 5$ sent 
mrfloridadude1 11-15-201111-26-2011Success 111/12011 topps long hand written letter and $2 donation we'll see.... amazing im 2/2 with Manning and was surprised because after siging for everyone in october he has signed very little in November
Eddie_2 11-15-201111-26-2011Success 111/1signed 1/1 in 12 days, no fee!! Amazing success and my first try. TY Mr. Manning. 
hotbox 11-14-201111-28-2011Success 141/1No Fee! 
lotsofautos 11-14-201111-28-2011Success 141/1Signed my custom, beautiful signature. Thanks Peyton and Sportscardforum! 
JayHo7284 11-13-201101-17-2012Failure 651/1Got my mini football back unsigned but he did include a signed 8x10...still a failure, though 
tribefan97 11-10-2011 Pending -1/0sent an index card because i couldn't find a topps card. hope to get it back in the next 2 weeks 
rarehunter916 11-10-201108-01-2012Success 2641/1Sent figurine base, LOR, SASE, $5.00 donation - Sent back sign 8x10 - Thank you Mr Manning! 
autosftw22 11-09-201111-18-2011Success 92/1signed 1, didnt sign other. still sick! 
whoppdogg 11-09-201112-02-2011Success 232/1Sent 2 cards, recieved both back only 1 signed 
Csarge8 11-08-201101-19-2012Success 721/1  
juflo331 11-07-201112-03-2011Failure 261/11 card. This is a stamp! 
bball15fan 11-07-201102-03-2012Failure 881/0sent mini helmet...for 3rd time...hoping to get it signed! 
kardkid 11-04-201111-22-2011Success 181/1i sent a dollar for his charity, i can't believe he sent it back! 
arfmax 11-03-201111-09-2011Success 61/110 Topps Magic (enclosed $5 donation, returned donation) 
ZG3411 11-02-201111-09-2011Success 71/1sent playoff continder card came back signed!
ZG3411 11-01-201111-05-2011Failure 41/0sent a 8x10 retturned with PP 
bounty331 10-31-201111-07-2011Success 71/1wow....just wow! 
knicksfannumba1 10-29-201111-07-2011Success 91/1Signed card. 
soccer1072 10-28-201111-05-2011Pending 81/11 Week turnaround!!!! Super fast! Excellent! 
rarehunter916 10-28-201111-05-2011Success 81/1Sent 1 card, LOR, SASE - My first successful TTM! Thank you Mr. Peyton! 
JMelz 10-26-201111-10-2011Success 151/1Signed 2009 Topps Mayo 
loki1230 10-25-201111-05-2011Success 111/1Returned my 2011 Score signed in blue and returned my check! One of my favorite returns yet! 
ZG3411 10-21-201110-29-2011Failure 81/0sent a 8x10 and $1.0, returned unsigned with a 5x7 PP 
Dshoblo 10-21-201110-31-2011Success 101/1Sent topps platinum card & $5 cash donation w/note returned quickly signed in blue sharpie. Very nice
Ryan4614 10-20-201110-30-2011Failure 101/1Preprint again 2nd time 
67anbh 10-20-201111-12-2011Success 231/1Signed my chrome card!!!!! 3rd success from Mr. Manning!!!!!!!!!!! 
cardguy8889 10-18-2011 Pending -1/0sent 2009 bowman 
RockiesFan33 10-18-201110-31-2011Success 131/1Signed my custom
MVick7 10-18-201110-24-2011Success 61/1I did not want to send to him again but I did not like the way my first one came out because it faded, I sent a topps chrome rookie reprint and it came back perfectly signed Thanks Peyton now I am done sending to him 
kyleEMT 10-18-201110-28-2011Success 101/1semi success, sent my 8x10 back unsigned with a pre print 
ZG3411 10-17-201110-24-2011Success 71/1sent a superbowl patch card letter and $1. Signed it
gysot 10-11-201110-19-2011Success 81/1Signed my 8X10 with 5 dollar donation. Thanks Peyton! 
JayHo7284 10-11-201110-31-2011Success 201/1Sent Peyton a baseball to see if he'd sign it...and he DID! Right on the sweet spot!
JayHo7284 10-11-201110-27-2011Success 161/1Got my Colts license plate signed. Now sending off to Dallas Clark.
MVick7 10-08-201110-14-2011Success 61/1Sent a topps card and 5 bucks sent back it back signed in blue finaly after 3 tries 
scoot51015 10-08-201105-26-2012Success 2311/1Sent $10; didn't sign mini helmet, sent signed picture 
Riggs 10-05-201110-14-2011Success 91/1Great signer, FAST turnaround.. returned my check also 
67anbh 10-05-201110-17-2011Success 121/1Signed My card!!!!!!! This is my second success from him in the same month!!!!!!!!!!! 
phillykid15 10-01-201110-14-2011Success 131/1Signed a 1998 bowman rookie card. Looks sweet, no donation needed. 
67anbh 09-27-201110-08-2011Success 111/1Signed my Donruss Elite!!!! go to http://youtube.com/67anbh to view my success' 
MSUspartans 09-27-201110-05-2011Success 81/1signed '07 Upper Deck in only nine days!! 
ZG3411 09-26-201110-03-2011Success 71/1Sent a card no donation sent back a singed 5x7!! 
juflo331 09-20-201109-30-2011Success 101/1Rookie reprint. Check out all my success at www.youtube.com/user/juflo331 
bcardsrock35 09-20-201110-16-2011Success 262/2Included $5 
phillykid15 09-05-201109-10-2011Failure 51/0Sent a pre-print and my card. 
bcardsrock35 09-04-201109-26-2011Success 221/1SICK!!! SENT $5!!! 
67anbh 09-03-201109-10-2011Failure 71/0Got a pre-print and my card back unsigned :( i may try again when he is less busy. He probably didn't sign because he had neck surgery. 
Riggs 09-03-201109-10-2011Failure 71/0returned unsigned, also sent back my $5. will try again later 
tboculosis 09-03-201109-24-2011Success 211/1Received my trading card back signed in blue sharpie. Sent $5 donation. 
mrfloridadude1 08-22-201108-30-2011Success 81/1sent 8x6 long hand written letter $10 and sase SO AMAZED!!!! Awesome success!
MSUspartans 08-18-201108-25-2011Failure 71/0Received card back unsigned & a small pre-print picture of Peyton. 
bball15fan 08-17-201109-07-2011Failure 211/0sent mini helmet recieved picture 
brendenw 08-15-201112-16-2011Success 1231/0Sent a SASE + 2 Page Letter + Photo. No Donation. Came Back SIGNED. WOW! 
mmalpedo01 08-10-201108-29-2011Success 191/1Signed 8x10 with blue sharpie. Damaged pretty badly in the mail. Will post pics in success thread later. 
Jeremy_Falcons 07-30-201108-24-2011Success 251/1He signed my card with a $5 dollar donation. It looks great.
lotsofautos 07-27-201108-04-2011Failure 81/2Sent 8x10 with donation and a very sincere letter, received my 8x10 unsigned with a pre-print. 
McJoshvitt 07-22-201108-03-2011Success 123/1Sent 3 cards, hand written letter, and $10 to PeyBack Foundation. Recieved 1 of 3 signed and my check back. 
brendenw 07-22-201110-16-2011Failure 861/0Sent Sase+Letter+card! NO DONATION! 2nd attempt (sent my other the 15th) Got it back un-signed.. STRANGE... 2 weeks later i got back the one i sent on the 15th back signed! 
Jdiz58 07-06-201107-16-2011Failure 101/0Returned 8x10 unsigned....Darn, will have to try again after football season. I included a check for $10. 
Ryan4614 07-05-201107-16-2011Failure 111/0Sent an 8x10 and a $10 donation and got my 8x10 back unsigned and a crappy preprint 
ZG3411 06-30-201109-22-2011Success 841/1Sent 06 SP Authentic which he signed in blue. No donation sent. Sweet suscess!
ZG3411 06-30-201108-10-2011Success 411/1signed my card with no donation
JayHo7284 06-29-201107-18-2011Success 191/1Signed my mini helmet with a $12 donation...guess I wrote a pretty good letter.
arfmax 06-29-201107-19-2011Success 201/1sent 09 UD Goodwin Champions with $10 check, returned the check, and signed card in blue 
ONUwr81 06-25-2011 Pending -1/0Sent custom 8x10 with $10.00 donation 
ONUwr81 06-25-201107-21-2011Success 261/1Sent $10 donation and polite letter
RockiesFan33 06-15-201109-21-2011Success 981/1Signed my custom
lizard-jd 06-15-201105-26-2012Success 3461/1Sent custom previously signed by Irsay & Polian plus $10 donation. Returned my pic unsigned plus my $10 check but included his own 8x10 signed pic. Figured I would never see this again... 
ar1888 06-11-201106-18-2011Failure 71/0Sent 8x10 and $5.00 donation. Kept the donation sent 5x7 preprint. 
beachboy22 06-08-201106-19-2011Success 111/1sent 8x10 with donation. Recieved my 8x10 back unsigned but he did send a 5x7 autographed so im not complaining! 
Big_MO 06-06-201106-13-2011Success 71/1Pen he used started out weak, but ended up Great! 
crazylax30 06-06-201106-13-2011Success 71/1So excited looks great!!! Thank You Peyton 
Riggs 06-06-201105-31-2012Failure 3601/1just shy of a year.. sent mini & $25 donation, sent back mini unsigned with signed 8x10. kept my $$ 
bball15fan 05-26-201106-14-2011Success 191/1SI 8x10 
Riggs 05-21-201106-02-2011Success 121/1First return from Mr Manning this year for me... Great addition!!! $5 fee 
JayHo7284 05-03-201105-28-2011Success 251/1Signed my Colts license plate for free
Jeremy_Falcons 04-01-201104-11-2011Failure 101/0Returned check and card unsigned.. sent preprint card 
nubiggestfan70 03-07-201103-12-2011Failure 51/0Got card and $1 back with preprinted card 
white2128 01-28-201104-30-2011Success 911/1signed my 2010 Topps ALL PRO card. gave $5 donation or something like that 
kobe4mvp34 01-27-201102-27-2011Success 311/1sent 12x16 painting w/$20.00 cash donation-Got back painting Signed-keep 20.00 donation and sent a signed 8x10 
brentwin 01-21-201101-27-2011Failure 61/0fake pre print card 
saluki2002 01-17-201101-26-2011Failure 92/3Counting this as a failure, Received my cards unsigned and a small picture w/ stamp auto, sent $10 
spy231 01-17-201101-17-2011Failure 01/0No big deal. Just sent at the wrong time. Sent $5 with small custom. 
moneymatt 01-12-201102-25-2011Success 441/1sent a $5 donation..didnt sign my SI magazine but sent a signed 8x10..slightly smudged by im stoked about this one 
Rudickulous 01-07-201102-24-2011Success 482/4Technically though...preprint cards sent with my others unsigned...my donation was also returned. What? 
kobe4mvp34 01-07-201101-13-2011Failure 61/0sent jersey card-sent it back unsigned and gave me a pp card-i did use the same return address. 
Nhat.MTL 01-06-201101-17-2011Failure 111/0Got preprint card and my card back unsigned. 
Csarge8 01-03-2011 Pending -1/0  
white2128 12-29-2010 Pending -2/2Sent 2 2010 topps cards with a $5 donation. Fingers crossed.... 
REDANDGOLDPRIDE 12-22-201012-30-2010Success 81/1Signed my custom, included a $5 cash donation.
cwells52 12-20-201012-30-2010Success 101/0Very excited with this return.
gocrdnls25 12-08-201012-15-2010Success 71/1First Success! Received Card Back and Signed incredibly quickly.
kobe4mvp34 12-06-201012-20-2010Success 141/1sent $5.00 money order and 8x10-he signed the 8x10 and sent the money order back 
tampacannon 12-05-201012-17-2010Success 121/1Success! Sent Donation. Got a little dinged in mail but still a great return!
xtra-innings 11-30-201012-10-2010Success 101/18 for 8 this season!!
jmf42397 11-23-201012-04-2010Success 111/1Signed my 2010 Prestige in blue sharpie!!! Best success yet!!! 
ddc 11-22-201012-09-2010Success 172/1no donation, only signs 1 item per 
RyanRizz715 11-16-201011-27-2010Success 111/1Unbelievable! Returned my 8x10 signed BEAUTIFULLY in Blue Ink. Best Success Yet! 
mmalpedo01 11-15-201012-03-2010Success 181/1Signed my Pack of 2010 Donruss Classics! Pics in my bucket and success thread. 
aristocraticautog 11-11-201012-17-2010Success 361/1Recieved the card back with signature in blue sharpie. Awesome success and didn't send a donation either. 
Gridiron63 11-09-201011-19-2010Success 102/1Signed one of two in black sharpie. 
SESports 11-05-201011-23-2010Success 181/1Sent donation. Replaced sent card with another, but signed beautifully in fine, blue sharpie. I heard him say in an interview that if someone sends a card he doesn't have, he'll trade and sign it for the trouble. Great Guy! 
deeakay 11-01-201011-06-2010Success 51/15 days from WI to IN back to WI, signed in black. I picked this card up from a flea market this July just to send, then got lazy : )
cyberer 11-01-201011-11-2010Success 103/1Sent a 5 dollar donation and got a great auto fast! 
jmf42397 11-01-201011-08-2010Failure 71/0This time sent $5 donation and sent pre-print again 
jake 10-30-201011-08-2010Failure 91/0Sent a free card for him. He returned both cards unsigned And a crappy pre print 
REDANDGOLDPRIDE 10-27-201011-08-2010Success 121/1Pre-print CARD, not the photo.. A card.. Weird..
jmf42397 10-19-201010-30-2010Failure 111/1Sent back my CIC unsigned and sent pre-printed photo in his own envelope. 
xtra-innings 10-09-201010-29-2010Success 201/1 
StarburyMatrix3 10-08-201010-16-2010Success 82/1SIGNED 1 OF 2 CARDS, SENT THE UNSIGNED ONE BACK IN THE TOPLOADER AND THE SIGNED ONE LOOSE IN THE ENVELOPE
soccer1072 10-02-2010 Pending -1/0  
MNsportznut 09-30-201010-08-2010Success 81/1('52 bowman style) 2010 topps 
JVazz29 09-25-201010-04-2010Success 91/1Signed my custom. Awesome.... 
lambeauleap87 09-20-201009-30-2010Success 101/1Signed My Card In Blue Sharpie. 
Johntheguy100 09-20-201010-07-2010Success 171/1Cool success did not send donation 
Riggs 09-13-201009-18-2010Success 51/1Great signer, FAST turnaround.. $5.00 DONATION!! WELL worth it!! 
mattingly4232 09-09-201009-25-2010Success 161/1sent an 8x10, got his 8x10 back signed - it is signed in a different spot (slightly) and is definitely not an autopen! How great is Peyton for signing for his fans??? 
apc221339 09-07-201009-18-2010Success 111/1  
xtra-innings 09-01-201009-17-2010Success 161/1 
bulldogboy07 08-30-201009-12-2010Success 131/1Kept $5 donation, and got an AWESOME card signed 
pantherfan82 08-16-201010-16-2010Success 611/1SENT JUST CARD & SASE - NO DONATION
rdel444 08-10-201012-01-2010Success 1131/1Took a little while but got it back signed - spx card 
RockiesFan33 08-09-201008-16-2010Success 71/1Didn't sign my 8x10, but did send a signed 5x7! Great return!
snifs 08-01-201009-01-2010Success 311/1signed SI mag. sent $5 donation 
snifs 07-27-201008-28-2010Success 321/1sent $5 donation, signed my SI mag 
mmalpedo01 07-20-201009-03-2010Success 451/1Signed a 2009 Topps Magic (Univ of Tenn) with blue sharpie. SHARP! 
xtra-innings 07-20-201008-06-2010Success 171/1signed card
KGRulesThePaint 07-09-201008-05-2010Success 272/1Peyton auto is amazing on this card Peyton is my favorite qb 
pantherfan82 07-02-201008-07-2010Success 361/1SENT JUST CARD & SASE - NO DONATION
Boozler79 06-29-201008-05-2010Success 371/1Sent $20 donation, 8x10, LOR, SASE to foundation. Rcvd my 8x10 signed. Returned my donation. Great Success!!! 
Jeremy_Falcons 06-22-201010-04-2010Success 1041/1I included a $5 dollar donation. 
soccer1072 06-20-201008-06-2010Success 471/22 signed cards. One was beautiful but the other was smudged badly. Nevertheless, a GREAT success!
Biggums7 06-16-201008-06-2010Success 511/1  
brandon711 06-15-201008-05-2010Success 511/1sent one card and rec it signed looks great 
xtra-innings 06-11-201006-18-2010Success 71/11 week turn around...WOW!
SPB903 06-10-201006-21-2010Success 111/1Returned 8x10 unsigned, included 5x7 signed in black sharpie 
Riggs 06-05-201006-14-2010Success 92/1very quik... great success!!! sent small donation.. 
the305 06-01-201008-09-2010Failure 691/1sent $10 bill, they kept my money and returned my ticket stub UNSIGNED!!! EPIC FAIL! 
MNsportznut 06-01-201006-12-2010Success 111/1success after 3rd Try 
REDANDGOLDPRIDE 05-24-201006-03-2010Success 101/1Sent $5 donation, and he signed my custom!!!!
xtra-innings 05-20-201006-11-2010Success 221/1 
pantherfan82 05-17-201005-29-2010Success 121/1SENT JUST A CARD & SASE - NO DONATION - RECEIVED CARD BACK SIGNED
baseball10 05-04-201005-14-2010Success 101/1Sent 2009 UD SP card and $5 returned signed 
Biggums7 04-07-201004-17-2010Failure 101/0sent back card un-signed and sent a pp photo 
xtra-innings 04-02-201004-24-2010Success 221/1Card returned unsigned but included signed photo (not preprint) with donation
reggie_miller_fan 03-20-201004-05-2010Failure 161/0sent $5 and a card to get signed , they sent back an small unsigned photo and kept my sharpie 
BigRedMachine 02-27-201003-17-2010Success 172/12 Custom Cards + $5 Donation - What a surprise to open my envelope and find my custom signed by Peyton, returned the other card unsigned but I didn't really care.
braves505 02-17-201003-04-2010Failure 151/0recived a 5x7 photo with the smallest pre print auto ever 
xtra-innings 01-28-201002-12-2010Success 151/1Sent 5x7 photo with $5 donation (card returned unsigned)
indyreds 01-28-201002-20-2010Success 231/1$5 donation = auto 8x10 in my SASE and return of item I sent as well. 
bmullins18 01-21-201001-28-2010Success 71/0Sent back the triple threads card with $1 donation and recieved another 5X7 autographed. 
pantherfan82 01-14-201001-22-2010Success 80/1sent $5 donation received signed 5x7 
Biggums7 01-14-201001-29-2010Success 151/1  
JVazz29 01-12-201001-24-2010Success 121/1Signed my 4x6 custom - Included $3 donation 
bmullins18 01-11-201001-20-2010Success 91/1Sent a Peyton Manning Triple Threads with $5 donation and a one page letter, got back a 5X7 with auto and my card back w/out auto.
lizard-jd 01-10-201001-19-2010Success 91/1Signed his own 8X10 & sent my custom back ($5 cash). He obviously has a stack of these ready to go because I think he is rather busy these days ; - O !
stovie 01-01-201001-10-2010Success 91/1Signed Card in Blue Sharpie nice sig 3rd Success. 
Biggums7 12-28-200901-08-2010Success 112/1  
Riggs 12-28-200901-07-2010Success 101/1signed &personalized it.. very cool 
doubleMcards14 12-11-200901-04-2010Success 243/1Awesome success!! Sent $5 donation with cards.
jadezfire 11-19-200912-01-2011Success 7421/1Sent LOR, card, $5 donation- signed card 
blkdodge 11-03-200911-16-2009Success 131/1Signed 8x10 with donation 
dicekmvp 09-28-200910-17-2009Success 191/1Finally! Sent 8x10, got different 8x10 signed back! Included $2
chrisborene 09-24-200910-02-2009Failure 82/0sent a sporting news mag, and a card as well as a $15 dollar donation , ending up only getting back my unsigned sporting news mag and a 5x7 pic(not even a preprint) and took the card and silver sharpie,the foundation should "peyback" me for those items!!! 
pointskater 07-26-200908-19-2009Success 242/3Not only did he sign the 2 cards i sent but because they had a gloss finish the auto didnt stick well so he signed a card of his own and sent it too! 
Cmwill24 07-20-2009 Pending -1/0  
ar1888 07-06-200905-11-2010Success 3091/1Sent Sports Illustrated, and $20.00,returned signed and personalized 
Latko32 04-27-200908-18-2009Pending 1131/0  
Cmwill24 04-08-200905-18-2009Success 401/1Sent a small cash donation as well.
torrebroncos14 01-01-200901-09-2009Pending 80/0  
wongcastle 11-30-1999 Failure -0/0sent to a different address 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 67%    
Total number of submission on this address: 10
# of Success: 4  # of Failed: 2  # of Pending: 4
Instruction:
Added by:mr_mustard   Added on: 07-26-2009
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
wilcow 12-17-201302-04-2014Failure 491/1used SASE to return mini helmet unsigned 
braves505 11-12-201012-15-2010Success 331/1  
booger184 08-17-2009 Pending -2/008 Gridiron Gear and 09 topps 
indyreds 08-17-2009 Pending -1/0  
lambeauleap87 08-06-200908-21-2009Success 151/1Signed Topps Magic Card In Blue Sharpie 
Biggums7 08-01-2009 Pending -1/0  
cubsfan129 07-29-200912-29-2010Failure 5181/0  
smejus57 07-27-2009 Pending -1/0  
mr_mustard 06-16-200907-25-2009Success 391/1Signed 07 upper deck even put "please do not bend" on the front and back of the sase for me and taped the back of it too!!!!!!!! 
Biggums7 05-28-200907-31-2009Success 641/1Signed Trading Card 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 50%    
Total number of submission on this address: 2
# of Success: 1  # of Failed: 1  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:This is his home in Indianpolis.
Added by:mastervin636   Added on: 10-02-2009
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
RockiesFan33 12-03-201012-20-2010Success 171/1Signed my custom!
Manning94 06-08-200901-18-2010Failure 2242/0I sent a Topps Magic Historys best and Gridiron Gear base and got a Pre-print card. Fail! 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 0%    
Total number of submission on this address: 2
# of Success: 0  # of Failed: 1  # of Pending: 1
Instruction:
Added by:braves505   Added on: 03-04-2010
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
BaseballPhan101 10-07-201003-10-2012Failure 5201/0Sent date estimated. I will probably not get it back unfortunely. 
braves505 03-06-2010 Pending -1/0  
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 70%    
Total number of submission on this address: 40
# of Success: 21  # of Failed: 9  # of Pending: 10
Instruction:Send email to PeyBack foundation
Added by:skinsfan0521   Added on: 05-04-2010
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
bcornea81 07-15-2026 Pending -1/0Sent email request 
Jk72finfan 05-08-202605-11-2026Success 30/1Sent Peyton a nice email telling him why I was a fan. I wasn't expecting anything and he sent me a signed 8x10 
allenm1985 09-02-2022 Pending -1/0Sent an email 
JacksonJo 08-16-2022 Pending -1/0Sent email request 
Coombeer215 06-05-2022 Pending -1/0I sent him an email of how he made me so happy when he played idk if it works but if it does I will update this. 
Sam234 03-08-202208-15-2022Success 1591/1Sent email request and received actual SIGNED PHOTO! No preprint! This is my 2nd success from Mr. Manning. My favorite! 
jakebrandon 03-10-202103-11-2021Failure 10/0Sent email request; received reply to send in item 
AthletesAutograph 01-12-2016 Pending -0/0sent a heart felt email about how i aspired to be like him and how i admired his charity work and how i would like to donate. 
primetime27 11-18-2015 Failure -0/012 26 17 sent another request. 
bryson120 01-29-2015 Pending -0/0  
yankees02 06-20-2014 Pending -0/0Email request 
LeJHa 03-08-201404-19-2014Success 410/1Sent Email/ Got Preprint Picture 
chefsanders 12-05-201301-02-2014Success 280/1Preprint 
zachboy15 12-02-201301-03-2014Success 320/1nice auto 
freezeover98 10-13-201310-22-2013Success 90/1nice, high quality preprint 
primetime27 10-09-201311-15-2013Failure 370/1Received 5 x 7 color picture with a pre-printed signature. 
Autographs21 09-28-201310-03-2013Success 50/1Received a signed 8 by 10 from Peyton manning can tell the Difference in pre-print and this one absolute mojo 
richie894 07-25-201308-15-2013Failure 210/0submitted request thru foundation website. consider failure as got a pre-printed 7x5 pic. not real signature. 
Ryanmillerfan30 05-07-201305-13-2013Success 60/1Was hoping to get a real one like some people have been lucky to get but still really cool! 
wongcastle 04-26-201305-06-2013Success 100/1received pre-print color 5x7 
primetime27 01-07-201301-15-2013Failure 80/1received 5" x 7' pic with pre-printed or stamped autograph. same as pictures here. 
bkoon 12-12-201201-07-2013Success 260/18x10 think its a preprint 
MattsSportsCards 07-14-2012 Pending -0/0  
mbell 07-12-201207-27-2012Success 150/1Sent long email saying how big of a fan I am and asking for the autographed photo. Recieved tiny photo with pre-print auto. 
buriburi 06-26-201207-07-2012Success 110/1wrote this whole long email about how i was a fan since i was a kid and got back a signed 8x10. can tell its real bcuz i got a pre-print before and compared it. 
ProWolf 06-03-201206-15-2012Failure 120/0Got back a worthless tiny little pre-printed mini picture back. 
Csarge8 05-28-2012 Pending -0/0  
primetime27 04-26-201205-01-2012Failure 50/0Got a pre-printed mini picture back. 
ovechkin8 03-08-201204-03-2012Success 250/1  
Colts15 02-28-201203-08-2012Success 90/1I call it a success. Got an 8x10 pre-print. Still nice that they took the time to send it to me. 
be.connors 08-21-201108-26-2011Failure 50/1Mad pre print 
Csarge8 08-02-201108-06-2011Failure 40/0Got a tiny "card" no autograph..my manning jinx continues.. 
Jollywood 07-14-201107-23-2011Success 90/1Received 5x7 signed in Blue Sharpie. Not a pre-print, you can tell the signature is on top of the picture, not part of it. 
schrag5 07-01-201107-23-2011Success 220/1Recieved signed 5x7! 
bebecerveza 06-16-201106-21-2011Success 50/1Funny I got the picture from the 5x7 but it was the size of a card with Pre-Print on it. 
Oak 05-21-201106-10-2011Success 200/1Sent me a 2003 Fleer Skybox Limited Edition card, Autographed 
wongcastle 12-30-201001-08-2011Success 90/1received pre-print color 5x7
joshh212 10-12-201001-01-2010Pending -2840/0  
Brewcrew246 05-10-201005-14-2010Success 40/1preprint 
skinsfan0521 04-27-201005-03-2010Success 60/1Sent email & received 5x7 AUTHENTIC autograph that some people are getting by mailing request to physical location. Slightly damaged in the mail, but still all good. 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 100%    
Total number of submission on this address: 2
# of Success: 2  # of Failed: 0  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:The PeyBack Foundation
Added by:aristocraticautog   Added on: 12-27-2010
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
mlbfan85 12-19-201112-30-2011Success 112/1fast return sent $2 signed one but sent both back will have to resend the other again. 
Spongebob 12-22-201001-03-2011Success 121/1sent 1 dollar donation, signed one card 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 40%    
Total number of submission on this address: 15
# of Success: 6  # of Failed: 9  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:c/o Broncos
Added by:scoot51015   Added on: 07-22-2012
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
mazefan72 03-10-201403-20-2014Failure 101/0returned card unsigned... 10 days 
packers1287 10-30-201312-06-2013Success 371/1  
dscards 09-12-201310-14-2013Failure 321/0Returned 8x10 and donation with a preprint 
cubbies4ever 09-02-201310-15-2013Failure 431/02010 Topps Unrivaled - Returned Card Unsigned, 43 days 
poppincurbs 11-09-201212-05-2013Failure 3912/0Sent LOR, 2 cards, SASE, received cards back unsigned in my SASE with my LOR. Bummer. 
JayHo7284 10-25-201211-05-2012Failure 111/0Received my ball back unsiged along with a very obvious (& crappy) pre-print...oh well. 
coxnick93 09-10-201209-24-2012Failure 141/0sent back my card unsigned in my sase 
JayHo7284 09-08-201210-15-2012Success 371/1  
antoine38 09-06-201209-15-2012Success 90/1Received Broncos Postcard, Okay
w8lifter28 09-05-201209-15-2012Failure 101/0Card was sent back unsigned 
biggsy2323 09-01-201209-17-2012Failure 162/0Sent back both cards, none signed. 
Fielderautos28 08-31-201209-15-2012Failure 151/0Wrote him a nice letter, just put my card and letter in the envelope and sent it back. geez 
browns3312 08-23-201208-31-2012Success 81/1Unbelievable 1/1 2011 Score fot the set 
scoot51015 07-23-201208-15-2012Success 231/0Somewhat a success: unsigned Colts mini helmet and Broncos pre-print 
KyleCaso 03-27-201205-05-2012Success 391/1Awsome Success. Sent a 2010 Topps chrome Refractor and it came back signed! Sent it the day after he signed!!! 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 50%    
Total number of submission on this address: 154
# of Success: 71  # of Failed: 71  # of Pending: 12
Instruction:
Added by:wolfman4christ   Added on: 12-29-2012
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
Schuler757 08-07-2018 Pending -1/0  
Piester 06-06-201806-11-2018Failure 51/1  
cutchamin 01-16-201801-30-2018Success 141/1  
jimmyf21 11-15-201712-02-2017Failure 172/0mailed 2 cards and sase - Return To Sender 
Baldones 10-17-201710-15-2017Failure -251/0Sent One Mini Helmet and 50 Cards for him to keep. (3rd Try) RTS 
jimmyf21 08-09-201709-01-2017Success 234/1mailed 4 cards and sase - received 1 card signed in black and 2 cards returned unsigned i guess he kept 1 for his collection 
Cjohnson1221 06-23-201707-22-2017Success 291/11 card not enough, wish I would have sent one more. 
hoekrs01 03-03-201703-28-2017Success 241/1Signed a 2009 Sp Athentic with no donation 
petedah3at 02-23-201703-20-2017Success 241/1Sent 5x7, Letter, and SASE, received another 5x7 photo back signed. Great!! looks like a real sharpie to me.
zooiiks 01-26-201703-02-2017Success 351/1He sent back a diff 8x10 but that's fine w/ me! Sent LOR, SASE and 8x10
MichaelHorwitz 01-04-201701-05-2017Pending 11/02 Cards and LOR 
jg0516 12-30-2016 Pending -1/01 11x14 
jasonj 11-01-201612-01-2016Success 301/1Signed my photo. After two failures, I tried the address again... it was forwarded to the Peyback Foundation in Colorado 
zooiiks 10-31-201612-20-2016Success 502/1Signed 1 of 2. I'm happy. Sent LOR, SASE and 2 8x10s
mrdavidjb 01-16-201601-26-2016Failure 102/0Received a note stating note saying Mr. Manning was unable to sign at this time. 
CubsPackersOilers 01-06-201603-10-2016Success 641/1recieved PP. 
marty77 12-30-201501-12-2016Failure 131/02015 Topps returned card unsigned 
Trevor44 12-21-201504-04-2016Success 1043/1Amazing success, I can't believe I got this back, best TTM success ever! 
Hobey21 12-17-201501-06-2015Failure -3452/1Sent back my cards unsigned but included an autopen 5x7 
Philly4Life 12-08-201512-14-2015Failure 61/0Sent Colts mini helmet, LOR, SASE and asked for an inscription. Got is back unsigned with a bent up piece of junk picture with a preprint auto :( 
broncosfan13 12-05-201512-19-2015Success 142/1EXTREME MOJO Signed one card for me a little smeared but still my best ttm yet! Thanks Peyton A.k.A the G.O.A.T! 
cubbies4ever 11-24-2015 Pending -1/02015 Score Team Leaders w/ Anderson, Thomas, Miller (Quad auto?) 
lh4augie 11-19-201512-02-2015Failure 131/0Trying again- 8X10 of Eli, Peyton, and Archie, already signed by Eli and Archie.- another failure. Going to try again, really want this signed 
dunkanarchy 10-30-201512-16-2015Success 471/1Sent 2014 Air Marshals Prizm, got forwarded to his Peyback in Indy, and he sent back the card unsigned, but signed a 5x7 for my dad. So happy to finally get my dad this, it'll be his christmas gift this year. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
htam0403 10-27-201511-09-2015Failure 131/0Disappointed to receive back unsigned. He clearly opened the taped top loader, but refused to sign the card. Will try again later with no protection. 
Hug-Hes 10-26-201511-07-2015Failure 121/0Disappointed to get this back unsigned. After getting Eli back I thought Peyton would sign as well. 
bigscoop13 10-19-201510-29-2015Failure 103/0Sent back all three cards and none of them signed. Was hoping he would at least sign one of them. This was my second try. Going to try and send one card this time, maybe third time is the charm 
Sjw3315 10-19-201511-23-2015Success 352/1First ttm ever sent. took long and got worried but he signed one I can't even believe it 
K5bulldog 10-16-201511-23-2015Success 381/1I was very surprised and happy when i got this. Quick turnaround. My son loves it. Thank you Mr. Manning! 
JayHo7284 10-10-201511-21-2015Failure 421/0  
lh4augie 10-10-201510-20-2015Failure 101/0Sending a photo of Archie, Peyton, and Eli, already signed by Archie.- sent back unsigned with my letter. 
bigscoop13 10-09-201510-17-2015Failure 83/0sent him three cards hoping to get at least one signed and I got all three cards back in my return envelope unsigned and my LOR gone. Gonna try my luck again 
Hobey21 10-07-201511-23-2015Success 472/1Signed one card! Great success from a great player! Thank you Mr. Manning! 42 Days! 
cbtvideos 10-03-201511-23-2015Success 511/1Sent one 2014 Broncos Panini Super Bowl XLVIII trading card, letter, and SASE. Got back trading card I sent unsigned but included a 2015 Score trading card, signed with a blue Sharpie. Sent back in SASE I sent.
Pedroia15TheBest 09-25-201510-03-2015Failure 81/0Second straight return without signing, and no explanation. Done trying until I see more successes. 
Soeren2811 09-25-201510-13-2015Success 182/0sent SI cover and TC, received PP and TC unsigned; TTM to Germany 
cal91697 09-24-201510-05-2015Failure 111/0Returned Card unsigned 
HouseOfCards 09-23-201510-08-2015Success 153/2Sent 3 cards, various vendors - returned cards unsigned, but included 2 pre-prints.
Goldenage 09-21-201510-03-2015Success 122/1Always an awesome success 
Sportsfan25 09-18-201510-03-2015Success 152/1  
xxmikekooxx 09-16-201509-25-2015Failure 92/1Returned my 2 8x10's and instead included a pre-printed 8x10. Very disappointed. 
Saint On Sundays 09-13-2015 Pending -1/0  
BLawson87 09-03-2015 Pending -1/0Sent 1 Tennessee Jersey 
babco-luca 08-26-201509-12-2015Success 171/1AMAZING SUCCESS 
Nlach 08-26-201509-08-2015Failure 131/01 card.... 
Coltron57 08-24-201509-12-2015Success 191/14x6 signed by Eli and Archie. Came back signed, stoked to have all 3 on one photo! 
EKritzell 08-24-201509-11-2015Success 181/1Sending a card, hoping for the best // returned signed in Blue Sharpie with a card about donating to St. Vincents hospital
frazier114 08-17-201509-15-2015Success 293/1sent 3 cards and got 1 back signed very good auto no smears clean looking
w8lifter28 08-10-201509-12-2015Success 331/1Signed his own Score card. Huge Success!
NYYanks2016 08-03-201508-20-2015Success 172/1HUGE SUCCESS. Sent him 2, returned 1 but who cares. Smudged the autograph a little, but that fine! An awesome success. Thank you Mr. Manning! Good luck to the others that sent it out! 
67anbh 08-03-201508-12-2015Failure 91/0Sent my 4x6 back unsigned. 
marty77 08-03-201508-19-2016Failure 3821/0card w/donation 
SyxxSynse 08-03-201508-22-2015Success 192/1Didn't work through Foundation, so I'll try again...Success! Sent two cards, received Broncos card back unsigned but signed 2014 Upper Deck Tennessee card. 19 days. Thank you, Mr. Manning!
lh4augie 07-10-201508-01-2015Success 221/1Giving this another try- sending SI Sportsman of the Year Cover- YES! Better luck this year- Signed in black sharpie- including postcard with information about donating to his charity. 
raywhite24 05-18-201506-01-2015Success 141/1Date is approximate, not exact 
bboonie53 12-30-201401-09-2015Failure 100/02 8x10s/came back unsigned and with no note 
chefsanders 12-19-201401-22-2015Failure 341/0  
frazier114 12-18-201412-29-2014Failure 112/0sent 2 cards for like 7th try at getting his auto and got my cards back unsigned no explanation or note or nothing No Longer a Fan damn dont know what it takes to get him to sign 
arinesmith 12-17-201412-26-2014Failure 91/1Sent back using my SASE. Sent LOR, silver sharpie and mini helmet 
spikeowen 12-04-201412-30-2014Failure 261/0Hoping I get the timing right...nope 
sml8bp 11-03-201412-16-2014Success 431/1Sent 1 cards with SASE from Korea, signed black sharpie, added jersey #, card got bent in the mail, but I'm still good...https://www.pinterest.com/sml8bp/
BLawson87 11-03-201411-15-2014Success 121/1Sent 1 Tennessee mini football; Received football back unsigned, and a 5x7 photo with an authentic autograph sent from Peyback foundation.. I'll take it! 
raywhite24 11-03-201412-01-2014Failure 281/0Card unsigned with a note from the broncos saying he's unable to sign at this time 
chefsanders 10-20-201411-06-2014Failure 171/0rts 
reece795 10-11-201403-03-2015Failure 1432/0  
CubsPackersOilers 10-10-201411-14-2014Failure 351/0returned unsigned. 
raywhite24 10-04-201410-20-2014Failure 161/0Returned unsigned 
dunkanarchy 10-01-201411-17-2014Pending 471/0Please ignore 
jasonj 10-01-201410-08-2014Failure 72/0Sent my items unsigned in my sase w/ nothing else 
dunkanarchy 10-01-201410-17-2014Failure 161/0Returned back unsigned. Asked to have it written out to my dad. I may try that home address down at the bottom 
alf7624 09-29-201410-07-2014Failure 82/0Sent (2) 8x10s, SASE & LOR. Received my 2 pics back unsigned, with a Pre-Print photo.... I knew it was coming based on all the recent failures. Ill try again eventually. 
jaymz887 09-28-201410-03-2014Failure 51/0The big Denial 
coltsjal 09-27-201410-04-2015Failure 3723/0sent back in my SASE with cards unsigned 
Redsox1253 09-25-201410-04-2014Failure 92/2Took my two card unsigned and returned in my sase 
marty77 09-25-201410-04-2014Failure 91/0  
padsdsu 09-23-201410-07-2014Failure 141/0Returned in SASE not signed 
mets86 09-23-201410-07-2014Failure 141/1sent 11x14 got the dreaded pre print 
23jumpman 09-23-201410-04-2014Failure 111/0card got sent back unsigned. no reason given 
67anbh 09-22-201410-06-2014Failure 142/0  
pzero 09-18-201412-12-2014Success 851/1Sent SASE, Letter, and 8x10 got it signed and personalized to my cousin for Christmas. Amazing return!
Tdjimmyp5 09-18-201410-05-2014Failure 172/0Sent drawing and card. Kept drawing sent back card. Trying again 
etomford 09-08-201409-19-2014Failure 111/0Trying agian - sent back unsigned. This was the last time I try with him 
njjefff73 09-08-201409-18-2014Success 101/1Sent a 2014 Score Football card and requested personalization for my son. Received card back signed and personalized in 10 days
dunkanarchy 08-26-201409-18-2014Success 232/1Second try and I got one card signed! So happy about this, but I wanted to get one for my dad. I may try again. 
raywhite24 08-21-201409-13-2014Failure 231/0Returned card unsigned 
spikeowen 08-12-201409-19-2014Success 382/1Gonna try again...Simply Wow! Thank you Mr. Manning
spikeowen 07-30-201408-11-2014Failure 122/0Sent 2 RC's for my two boys, wish us luck! - Well, quick turnaround, returned both cards unsigned, no notes included, bummer. 
Hwood65 07-10-201408-11-2014Failure 322/0Returned unsigned cards in my SASE. Would love to get his signed card some day. Hopefully he will have more time after he retires:) 
lh4augie 07-05-201408-12-2014Failure 381/0Sending SI Cover... hope to get this back- Got it back, but unsigned. 
Kmbtheone 06-26-201407-05-2014Failure 91/0Note saying to busy to sign 
BillyOcean 04-21-2014 Pending -1/0  
etomford 04-09-201404-17-2014Failure 81/0returned card unsigned in SASE 
chefsanders 03-21-201404-23-2014Success 331/1Sweet. Signed SI 
BillyOcean 03-18-201403-28-2014Failure 101/0RTS - Too busy 
bballcrazy10 03-10-201403-10-2014Success 02/2Signed 2 of 2! Last post got deleted so the dates arent correct! 
handifan2010 03-08-201403-21-2014Failure 121/0returned the card unsigned 
Kyledaly24 03-08-201403-17-2014Failure 82/0Rts 😔😔😔😔😔 
biggsy2323 03-07-201403-17-2014Failure 92/002 UD, 03 UD Returned unsigned. 
biggsy2323 03-07-201403-18-2014Failure 102/001 Donruss, 09 Donruss 
studdlypoohbear 03-04-201403-22-2014Failure 174/03rd time no luck 
chefsanders 01-20-201403-05-2014Success 441/1My best TTM ever. SI already signed by Archie 
Nygiants42 01-13-201403-04-2014Failure 501/0Returned card unsigned. 3rd try. Uggggghhhhhhh 
PhyteGuru 01-09-2014 Pending -1/0  
RealBrianD 01-07-201402-17-2014Failure 411/0sent back unsigned. used my SASE to send back. why not just RTS so i can save stamps? oh well, worth the try///Sent a sincere letter, blue sharpie and SI cover '2013 Sportsman of the year'...would be AMAZING to get back 
cy young 12-30-2013 Pending -1/0i really hope i can get this one signed 
cy young 12-30-201301-09-2014Failure 101/0really want to get this back bowman 13.I GOT A PIECE OF PAPER SAYING HE IS TO BUSY TO SIGN 
Ryanmillerfan30 12-26-201303-05-2014Failure 691/0returned unsigned, no expiation third time, will have to try again 
cy young 12-23-201303-06-2014Success 731/1hope he signs my ring of honor card.ABSOLUTELY BTEATHTAKING HE SIGNED IN BLUE GREAT TTM THX!!! PEYTON:) 
tberryment 12-17-201303-07-2014Success 801/1signed 2012 topps. Thank you Mr. Manning.
chitownautos 12-16-201303-07-2014Success 811/1'07 Topps DPP (Colts) + Letter/SASE...81 Days 
chefsanders 12-10-201311-03-2014Failure 3281/0no response 
Coltron57 12-09-201303-07-2014Success 881/1'07 Score to my favorite QB of all-time. Signed nicely in blue. Speechless even though I figured it was coming back. 
bboonie53 12-06-201303-05-2014Success 891/2'07 Topps Ring of Honor/Ok this is twice now this has happenend. Send card, signs card and is smudged, signs another card so now I get two, one bad one good. I won't complain. 
lh4augie 12-05-201303-06-2014Success 912/1Very happy to get this one back! Signed one of my cards. Definitely looks like a legit signature too! 
tberryment 12-05-2013 Pending -1/02012 topps 
torrebroncos14 12-02-2013 Pending -1/0sent a 13 prestige 
chefsanders 12-02-201311-03-2014Failure 3361/0no response 
mbell 12-02-201303-05-2014Success 931/1  
DownGoesFrazier 12-02-201303-07-2014Success 951/1Signed an 08 Icons card..CANNOT BELIEVE IT!! WHAT A SUCCESS! Thanks so much, Peyton! 
Boinks 11-23-201303-06-2014Success 1031/1Wow, wasn't sure I'd ever see this back. One of my best returns, Peyton rules!
chefsanders 11-18-201311-03-2014Failure 3501/08x10 
Bravesfan14 11-17-201303-07-2014Success 1102/1Got my card back signed in blue!!! 
padsdsu 11-16-201303-06-2014Success 1102/1Signed '13 bowman in blue sharpie...returned one unsigned.....awesome success 
Gibber99 11-15-201303-06-2014Success 1111/1Sent 2012 Topps / Excellent success, signed in blue sharpie 
kdawgcollecter 11-12-201303-06-2014Success 1142/1sent 2 cards- signed one, my best success yet 
rekless 11-11-201312-17-2013Success 361/1Sent an 8x10, recieved back today personalized in blue sharpie with #18 added. My first TTM success from the USA to Australia 
marty77 11-10-201303-06-2014Success 1161/1 
Colts15 11-07-201312-09-2013Success 321/1Not sure on the sent date, forgot about this one....sent a card, came back signed in blue with 18! 
cy young 11-02-201301-11-2014Failure 701/0love to get this back.UNABLE TO SIGN 
jaymz887 10-28-201312-05-2013Success 381/1sent one card and got returned autographed
mikedmatthews 10-26-201312-06-2013Success 412/14th try, signed 1 of 2. sent 1st 3 letters back unsigned. just keep trying if you don't get a success.
Ryanmillerfan30 10-22-201310-31-2013Failure 91/0  
bickel84 10-21-201312-05-2013Success 451/1  
Ryanmillerfan30 10-21-201310-31-2013Failure 101/0both envelops returned in sase, unsigned 
CO Rockies Fan 10-21-201312-03-2013Success 431/1OH MY GOSH! I sent this and got my card back signed. Awesome success. Hopefully it isn't ghost signed... 
Noles25 10-17-201311-15-2013Success 291/1Signed one Topps card and included his number.
sml8bp 10-12-201311-29-2013Success 482/1sent two cards, got 1 card back signed in black sharpie.. 
cbev3 10-11-201312-05-2013Success 554/2  
silojohnson 10-05-201312-02-2013Success 581/11 card (why not) // nice! Peyton signed my '12 Absolute... thank you Peyton! 
cubbies4ever 10-05-201310-12-2013Success 71/12010 Topps Unrivaled - Signed Black, 7 Days
marty77 10-03-201310-31-2013Failure 281/0Returned card unsigned w/o explanation. 
Noles25 10-01-201310-12-2013Success 111/1Got him on my second try. Card came back a little smudged but no complaints here. Awesome success!
Biggums7 09-25-201310-04-2013Failure 91/0  
ChuckXGoren 09-24-201310-10-2013Success 161/1Not a pre-print! Signed the 2013 Score card I sent. Amazing. 
Noles25 09-21-201310-10-2013Failure 191/0Sent one 2013 Prestige, returned unsigned. Going to try his foundation. 
pwmullen3 09-21-201310-11-2013Success 202/1  
torrebroncos14 09-20-201309-28-2013Success 81/1sent one 8x10.. I am really hoping this comes back!/ recieved photo back unsigned but sent his own 8x10!not sure if the auto is real though 
chefsanders 09-16-201310-10-2013Success 241/1Signed and personalized! Sweet 
Ryanmillerfan30 09-16-201310-12-2013Success 261/1Amazing return from the future hall of famer! I plan to mail a few more times to try and get some others signed 
Nygiants42 09-13-201309-26-2013Failure 131/0Didn't sign card. Nothing else in envelope. Bizarre. I'm going to try again. 
cy young 09-09-201309-16-2013Failure 71/0ring of honor card hoping like crazy that he signs it.HORRIBLE HE DIDNT SIGN CARD DONT EVEN THINK HE TOOK OUT OF THE CASE 
Riggs 09-03-201309-14-2013Success 111/1sweet success, signed 1 card 
delones24 08-14-201309-13-2013Success 301/113 Prestige
wolfman4christ 12-29-201201-10-2013Failure 121/0Sent my card back unsigned along with the gospel tract I sent him. 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 44%    
Total number of submission on this address: 52
# of Success: 21  # of Failed: 27  # of Pending: 4
Instruction:C/O Denver Broncos
Added by:pwmullen3   Added on: 10-12-2013
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
kactusjakk 01-26-201602-13-2016Failure 181/0Prob gonna fail, but - sent SI cover, LOR, SASE and $25 donation - returned, unsigned in my SASE with my check 
JimCant 01-25-201601-24-2017Failure 3652/0Sent 8x10 photo and SI cover with SASE. Writing this off as it has been over a year. 
broncosfan13 01-01-201612-15-2016Success 3491/1MOJO signed my card smeared a lot but still an amazing success! Thanks Mr.Manning!! 
Pedroia15TheBest 12-31-201501-15-2016Failure 151/0Received my 8x10 back unsigned, with a preprint 8x10. Giving up on trying him until I see a string of successes. 
CelciusII 12-29-2015 Pending -1/0w/ $5 for his Children's Hospital 
bigscoop13 12-14-201512-26-2015Failure 120/2i noticed Manning started signing, my daughter even got him to sign for her. So I decided to give it a go one more time making it my fourth attempt. I get back a little piece of paper saying sorry but Mr. Manning is unable to sign-Denver Broncos 
gsy971 12-11-201512-26-2015Failure 151/0got the dreaded 
IPAutos22 12-05-2015 Pending -1/0Sending 1 Card To Mr. Manning 
Ebys23 11-28-201512-08-2015Failure 101/012 Absolute, 6th attempt!!!!- yet another failure just freakin sign!!!!!!!!! 
CelciusII 11-09-201512-22-2015Success 431/1Finished the Manning trifecta! 
TexasTTMer 11-08-201512-19-2015Success 411/1Surprisingly Got this back! 
tigermiggy24 11-02-201511-24-2015Success 221/1Holy cow!!!! Can't believe he signed my rookie card. Sent no fee. 
TalleyHog34 10-26-201512-18-2015Failure 532/0Sent LOR with SASE and 2 cards along with 10.00 check to PeyBack. Here goes nothing. Pre prints 
BoSoxFan4235 10-20-201511-23-2015Success 341/1I decided to take a shot... My first time sending to Manning. OMG!!! He signed my card! This might be my best success ever! No donation sent 
bigm19792002 10-19-201511-02-2015Failure 141/0Sent card back 
Ebys23 10-16-201510-24-2015Failure 81/012 Absolute 
diback34 10-15-201510-26-2015Failure 111/0second attempt , sent card back unsigned 
mrREALiTi 10-07-2015 Pending -1/0  
Coolsportscards 10-05-201510-16-2015Success 111/1Sent 1 card, LOR, SASE - Returned 1 card signed, 2015 Prestige in Blue Sharpie, THANK YOU PEYTON!!! 
diback34 10-02-201510-14-2015Failure 121/0sent back fast ...at least he sent card back ... failed 
Ebys23 09-26-201510-11-2015Failure 151/012 Absolute 
BSRice 09-26-201511-23-2015Success 581/1 
jwongnyy 09-11-201505-17-2017Failure 6142/0Sent 2 4x6; writing off - retired 
Pedroia15TheBest 09-09-201509-24-2015Failure 151/0Returned unsigned 
air44bg 08-31-201510-03-2015Success 332/2Sent a photo of Archie, Eli & Peyton, already signed by the other 2 with an SI Cover, Peyton signed both (after 3 previous failures) 
Yanksfan876 08-21-201509-04-2015Failure 141/0Returned card in SASE unsigned 
Orange October 08-14-201509-19-2015Success 361/1Sent letter, card, SASE - very happy to get this back signed!!
spikeowen 08-12-201509-11-2015Success 301/1Flair rookie - boy What a great return. Thanks Mr. Manning!
Ebys23 08-11-201512-17-2015Failure 1281/0sent with donation 
frazier114 07-26-201508-20-2015Success 253/1sent 3 cards and got my 2014 topps mini throwback card back signed super Success! !!!!
Trevor15 07-16-201508-20-2015Success 351/1Gonna try it again just to see what happens lol........ success!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 
alf7624 06-29-201507-28-2015Failure 291/0giving it another try...... Lost again!!! Garbage Pre-Print photo again.... 
Trevor15 06-10-201506-27-2015Success 171/1Awesome success 
Ebys23 06-09-201506-20-2015Failure 111/0sent with 2$ donation- sent card back unsigned will try again 
Mogilny89 04-29-201505-19-2015Failure 201/0Time to get denied, again.. 
spikeowen 03-23-201504-12-2015Failure 201/0Gonna try again... 
biggsy2323 12-15-2014 Pending -1/001 Topps 
HouseOfCards 09-21-201412-11-2014Success 812/1Sent 2 cards. Returned 1 card signed, the other unsigned. Also included a postcard for his foundation. OMG! Thanks PM!
spikeowen 09-20-201410-06-2014Failure 161/0Striking while the iron is hot...it's not :( 
csulli13 08-18-201409-16-2014Success 291/1Send back a signed card! Slightly smudged in transit, but this was a hail mary. Awesome guy.
Mogilny89 06-17-201407-02-2014Failure 151/0sending 1. Hoping for the best!-FAIL 
JayHo7284 03-13-201404-18-2014Success 361/1  
ITStheCHAD13 02-26-201403-10-2014Failure 112/0Sent 2 4x6 photos...Recieved both 4x6 back with note saying Mr. Manning was unable to sign at this time 
WarHorse 01-17-201403-04-2014Success 461/12010 Prestige signed in blue. Future HOF hands down.
adrian28 12-28-201303-09-2014Failure 718/0this would be incredible to get backi wish he would have signed them 
JayHo7284 12-20-201301-06-2014Failure 171/0  
baseballfanatic16 12-12-201312-30-2013Failure 182/0Sent back unsigned 
Goldenage 10-25-201311-07-2013Success 131/1A little smudge but no complaints! 
bcool022 10-23-201310-31-2013Failure 81/0send my card back immediately unsigned 
mayne1984 10-02-201311-30-2013Success 591/1SIGNED 1 CARD!!!!THANK YOU MR. MANNING!!!!!HERE'S THE LINK FOR VIDEO http://youtu.be/QwymMbaVzJw 
pwmullen3 09-21-201310-11-2013Success 202/1Sent 2, he returned both, 1 signed. Great Success
baseballfanatic16 09-19-201310-10-2013Success 211/1Signed 8x 10 Action Photo. Great success 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 29%    
Total number of submission on this address: 7
# of Success: 2  # of Failed: 5  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:
Added by:xxcollectingxx   Added on: 01-04-2014
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
JayHo7284 04-19-201905-08-2019Failure 191/0RTS - Refused 
eagles5 05-18-201406-21-2014Failure 341/0send card back unsigned a donation 
arobertson 05-01-201406-02-2014Failure 321/0RTS. REALLY upset about this one. I have sent 3 times to him without a success. I had a signed card of his but I think it was stolen or accidentally thrown out. It meant so much to me :( Time to send off again... 
studdlypoohbear 02-20-201403-04-2014Failure 124/02nd time failure. They must get a lot of mail there they already had a sticker made up of where to send Broncos mail to. 
JayHo7284 02-07-201403-06-2014Success 271/1  
JayHo7284 01-11-201401-31-2014Failure 201/0  
unreal2k5 11-25-201303-07-2014Success 1021/1Sent 2013 Score card and 5 dollars. Got card back signed. Auto looks like pen died first time and a lil sloppy. But I still received Signed card back. 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 31%    
Total number of submission on this address: 13
# of Success: 4  # of Failed: 9  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:Home Addy.
Added by:bryson120   Added on: 09-06-2014
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
eshelton13 01-30-202302-27-2023Failure 281/0Sent 1 card, SASE, and LOR. RTS with address blacked out. 
superrc 07-14-2020 Failure -1/0Write off as loss 
geowelling 12-02-201912-23-2019Success 211/1quick turn around 
delones24 08-14-201709-05-2017Failure 223/011 Topps, 08 Icons, 09 Philadelphia - RTS 
delones24 08-01-201708-24-2017Failure 231/015 Platinum - RTS 
jimmyf21 06-15-201708-08-2017Failure 544/0mailed 4 cards and sase - Return To Sender, Attempted - Not known, Unable To Forward 
JayHo7284 04-05-201705-15-2017Success 402/2  
JayHo7284 11-25-201501-15-2016Failure 511/0  
LUKASttms 09-03-201510-01-2015Success 280/0  
dunkanarchy 10-22-201411-03-2014Failure 121/0RTS DO NOT SEND HERE. 4th attempt in trying to get my dad a Peyton signature and all have failed. 
Striker83 10-18-201410-30-2014Failure 121/0Sent LOR, SASE, 8x10 and check made out to his donation. Worth a shot./RTS. Put sticker over address that had Broncos address on it. 
w8lifter28 10-13-201411-03-2014Failure 211/0Return to sender 
Hwood65 09-18-201410-11-2014Success 232/2Tried the team address and cards got sent back unsigned. Figured I would try this address and it was a success. This one was a complete surprise, I didn't expect it to work. Thanks so much Mr. Manning. We have Archie and Peyton, now just need Eli. 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 65%    
Total number of submission on this address: 427
# of Success: 250  # of Failed: 135  # of Pending: 42
Instruction:
Added by:NolansCards   Added on: 12-16-2016
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
Brewers34gc 3/8/2104-01-2021Failure 231/0RTS 
Jk72finfan 02-24-202604-03-2026Failure 371/0RTS, address blacked out. Card returned 
nbf5013 11-03-202511-22-2025Failure 191/0SASE, typed letter, 8x10, addressed to PeyBack Foundation—RTS 
jpritchett 10-10-2025 Failure -1/0hand written note - $10 donation - RTS 
nbf5013 09-20-202510-28-2025Failure 381/18x10, typed LOR, SASE—-RTS 
Hcowher17 08-05-202508-27-2025Failure 221/1RTS and address scribbled out 
Pearly1 07-07-2025 Failure -1/0duplicate - disregard 
Pearly1 07-07-202508-04-2025Failure 281/01 card + SASE + HW Note - RTS 
DziC14 07-03-2025 Pending -1/0Card, note, SASE 
biscuitboy 04-27-202505-13-2025Failure 161/1RTS 
KB248FOREVER 04-23-202506-17-2025Failure 551/11 Card, 1 short HWLOR , SASE / Return To Sender but got everything back i sent. 
Calvinvesco 04-21-202505-12-2025Failure 211/0Return to sender. I had the correct address written down. They blacked it out and put RTS 
ncarter1320 03-31-202504-19-2025Success 191/1Sent Photo with return envelope included a handwritten letter. Received photo back signed and personalized 
bboonie53 08-31-202409-25-2024Failure 251/02000 Topps, Trying again/RTS 
Khutch95 04-22-2024 Pending -1/01+ lor 
wadebute 03-18-202405-07-2024Failure 501/12023 panini / RTS / Not deliverable as addressed 
Rodneyaa 03-06-202403-19-2024Success 121/1Sent 1 card to sign it wasn’t signed but Peyton instead sent his own picture signed! Thanks Peyton! 
BruceyBoy 03-04-202405-14-2024Failure 701/1I LOVE Peyton Manning would love a success LOR SASE no fee! RTS Don’t use address!!!
nickbricewallace 01-29-202402-27-2024Failure 291/0RTS unable to forward 
rggedglory 01-14-2024 Pending -1/01 card 
Sthomp27 01-04-202401-24-2024Failure 201/0Taking a shot. RTS 
Falzone829 12-18-2023 Pending -1/0  
dantesdeals 11-25-202312-28-2023Failure 331/0LOR, SASE, 1 card - RTS with address crossed out in sharpie 
Finn43 11-20-202301-25-2024Failure 661/03rd times a charm? - Nope, RTS again. Not deliverable as addressed 
Finn43 10-28-202311-17-2023Failure 201/0Trying this a 2nd time. - RTS again with address blacked out 
SmellyBonobo 10-11-202311-07-2023Failure 272/2sent note and 2 cards, came back RTS, Refused 
rggedglory 09-30-202302-16-2024Failure 1391/11 card; update RTS 
jpollard 09-23-2023 Pending -1/0  
Lucaslesser 09-19-202310-09-2023Success 202/1Did not sign any of my cards, but sent a small picture with his signature. Thanks Mr.Manning! 
mastil 09-18-2023 Pending -1/0  
cgfl 09-07-2023 Pending -1/01 Card 
Robert9312 09-01-202310-14-2023Failure 431/0RTS address blacked out 
El Capitan 08-30-202309-19-2023Failure 201/0RTS 
kautrey29 08-30-202309-11-2023Failure 121/0RTS Bad Address 
dvsantan 08-09-202308-28-2023Success 191/1taking a shot; massive return! 
Nyleetch2c 08-01-202308-25-2023Success 241/1HWLOR SASE. Signed Simpsons 8x10 with inscription. Returned donation. 
BradenC123 07-26-202308-28-2023Success 331/1Sent 2021 Donruss, LOR, & SASE. Signed!! 
toddbonzalez 07-13-202308-10-2023Success 281/1sent donruss 2021 
recbball 07-12-202308-08-2023Success 271/1Sent LOR, SASE, 1 card. Received signed card.
rggedglory 07-01-202308-11-2023Failure 411/11 card; update RTS 
mastil 06-29-202307-08-2023Failure 91/1  
bboonie53 06-28-202307-12-2023Failure 141/02000 Topps/RTS!! 
Niccio36 06-26-2023 Failure -2/0Sent 2 custom trading cards with SASE, LOR, $20 donation -> Writeoff 
RH81 06-26-202307-19-2023Failure 231/1Rts 
JTMarlin 06-20-202307-11-2023Failure 211/0SENT PLAYOFF CARD TO SIGN. Return to Sender Fail 
mastil 06-20-202307-08-2023Failure 181/1Rts 
georgef3518 06-16-202307-13-2023Success 271/12015 topps and 20 check 
bboonie53 06-02-202306-16-2023Success 141/12000 Score 
mastil 05-27-202306-16-2023Success 202/1  
Khutch95 05-26-2023 Failure -1/01 + LOR 
JacksonB4513 05-02-202305-24-2023Success 221/1  
eshelton13 04-26-202305-16-2023Failure 201/0Sent 1 card, SASE, and LOR. RTS with address blacked out. 
mrchajr 04-18-202306-03-2023Success 461/1lor, sase, 2000 Score 
dish142002 04-05-202304-26-2023Failure 211/1$20….RTS 
chef 03-10-202304-04-2023Success 241/1$20 donation. Returned donation check and signed my Colts card. Thanks, Peyton! 
d0gbackwards 02-28-202304-04-2023Success 341/12022 donruss base
jeffadennis81 10-04-202210-17-2022Failure 131/0Sent $25 foundation donation, card & LOR to address on Peyback foundation Web site. RTS, including donation. No auto, but got my card & money back. 
geowelling 09-22-202210-11-2022Failure 191/0RTS 
JacksonJo 08-31-202209-24-2022Failure 241/0RTS 
JLemon 08-16-202208-27-2022Success 111/1 
LetsGoMets20 07-27-2022 Pending -3/0SASE, LOR and sent 13, 14 and 15 Topps 
crupe29 07-01-202207-26-2022Failure 251/0Sent one 8x10 and $10 donation. RTS 
Jasfazad88 05-10-202205-23-2022Failure 131/0RTS 
Fenix 04-09-202205-05-2022Failure 261/1+$5 and a handwritten note, Address was blacked out and handwritten RTS 
sampio 04-05-202204-30-2022Failure 251/1RTS 
RussS 03-18-202204-01-2022Success 141/1Sent 1 photo, a note to him and a SASE 
hilde9284 02-20-202203-20-2022Failure 271/0RTS 
Phillies 12-20-202101-19-2022Failure 301/0RTS 
dnahar 11-23-2021 Failure -0/0Sent donation and LOR for signed picture 
JPSD16 11-16-202101-19-2022Failure 641/01 card (2014 Topps Chrome), LOR, SASE/ RTS 
Sussy 10-27-202111-22-2021Success 261/1Sent card- did not sign but received signed photo!! Real auto!! 
Godzilla 09-25-202110-13-2021Failure 181/0RTS 
Tlezaj 08-12-202108-30-2021Success 181/1Sent 7/23,Handwritten RTS 8/10, Resent 8/12 and BOOM! $25 donation, signed card, no HOF 
andyvizzle 08-05-2021 Failure -1/0rts 
ahuggins81 06-26-2021 Pending -1/0Sent a LOR, $10, card and a SASE... 
JPSD16 05-28-202107-03-2021Failure 361/0RTS 
TFERN 05-26-202106-26-2021Failure 311/0Sent a card. Envelope was opened, letter taken out, and card was returned in my SASE unsigned. 
mtool 05-23-202106-15-2021Failure 231/0return to sender 
ahuggins81 05-22-202106-24-2021Failure 331/1Sent a LOR, card, $10 check and a SASE...rts 
JPSD16 05-21-202107-03-2021Failure 431/0RTS 
Will3119 05-21-202106-23-2021Failure 331/0Another attempt, another rts. 
ste513lee 05-17-2021 Pending -1/0  
rggedglory 05-14-202105-24-2021Failure 101/11 card; update RTS 
geowelling 05-14-2021 Failure -1/0sending 8x10 again...... 
Bdude 05-12-202106-11-2021Success 301/1  
Chooch08 05-10-202106-01-2021Failure 221/0RTS 
PhillyPhever99 04-23-2021 Pending -1/0Letter, SASE, 8x10 photo, $10 check to PeyBack Foundation. My first submission through SCF. Rolling the dice here. 
martyp83 04-21-202105-19-2021Failure 282/0Sent HWLOR, donation to foundation and 2 cards - received envelope back marked RTS 
Cmoney66 04-19-202105-10-2021Failure 211/0RTS 
rggedglory 04-16-202106-04-2021Failure 491/11 card; update rts 
Klummp 04-12-202105-07-2021Success 251/11 card hwlor sase 10$ AHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HoodaBest2k20 04-10-2021 Pending -2/0  
UnraveledDonut 04-09-202104-27-2021Failure 181/0RTS 
adamd 04-09-202104-30-2021Failure 211/0Failure RTS unable to foward 
Altego2099 04-08-202104-30-2021Failure 221/1RTS 
PolishMafia6969 03-24-202105-07-2021Success 441/1  
Will3119 03-22-202104-16-2021Failure 251/0Rts, refused. Bummer 
Kennysportscards 03-20-202104-05-2021Success 161/0One card 
mtool 03-20-202105-07-2021Success 481/1signed 1 card 
Stebbins25 03-19-202104-05-2021Success 172/1See My Returns On YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_3LfyaGrNGUluOY1y5VqOg 
Esmith22collector 03-18-2021 Failure -1/0sent back card unsigned took donation lame 
Greg2600 03-17-202103-27-2021Success 101/1Sent 8x10 Colts photo with $10 donation. Returned my photo unsigned but included real signed of his!
garybeats 03-15-202104-05-2021Success 211/1'06 Topps, $10 check to PeyBack Foundation
jtdonovan246 03-15-202103-29-2021Failure 141/1Sent 1 card, letter, SASE, and $10 donation. Sent card back unsigned. Sent a small signed picture in return. Didn't cash check for donation. 
Braveheart30 03-04-202103-15-2021Success 101/2Great Success!! 3/6 with Peyton 
spikeowen 03-01-202103-26-2021Failure 241/098Crown Royal - RTS 
MadCityCards 02-25-202104-05-2021Success 381/1  
mtool 02-23-202103-12-2021Success 171/1signed 1 card 
sttbstsmt 02-22-202103-12-2021Success 181/1No freaking way! I sent a $10 check to the PeyBack Foundation and his 1998 Pacific rookie card to be signed. We'll see. I addressed to the PeyBack Foundation. He cashed the check and returned it signed in blue sharpie! Beyond floored!! 
cardsandcoins14 02-21-202103-12-2021Success 191/0Success! So hyped about this one! 
MrHyde 02-19-202103-13-2021Pending 222/2Sent $5 for the PeyBack foundation. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
sacricketer 02-17-202103-17-2021Success 271/1Sent 1 card, letter, SASE 
Niccio36 02-16-202103-14-2021Success 261/1Sent custom trading card with SASE, LOR — $10 donation. Incredible success!
eh2000man 02-13-202102-26-2021Success 131/1Sent an 8 x 10 and a $10.00 donation. He sent a different 8 x 10 signed.
friendnw1 02-12-202103-12-2021Success 282/1My son sent him cards will see what happens..son sent letter got it backed signed sent letter..Sase..card 
short444 02-09-202103-15-2021Failure 331/1Mini Helmet, $20.....RTS 
reachrulz 02-08-2021 Failure -2/0RTS Undeliverable 
russevans 02-02-202103-12-2021Success 381/11 card + $10 
spikeowen 01-25-202103-03-2021Failure 371/018Immaculate Collegiate - $$ - returned everything in my SASE unsigned 
JPSD16 01-15-202102-08-2021Success 241/11 Card, LOR, SASE/Broncos card sent back signed. Instagram: jpsdnicklarkins 
Ricky7 01-15-202102-09-2021Success 251/1  
rggedglory 01-12-202102-08-2021Success 272/12 cards; update returned one signed, one unsigned. Curiously, signed Broncos not Colts :) 
blitzaceod 01-10-202102-08-2021Success 291/1Sent w/$20
TripleTTyler50 01-07-202102-25-2021Success 491/1Sent 1 8x10 photo, received my photo back unsigned and sent another signed 8x10 and returned my donation
JPSD16 01-05-202103-13-2021Failure 671/01 Colts card, LOR, SASE/RTS 
geowelling 01-05-202102-03-2021Failure 291/1Fail Refused - wanted everyone to see. Is he done? Will make to fail soon. Wanted for people to see.
Altego2099 12-31-202002-08-2021Success 391/1SASE, LOR, 1 Card, Donation: Received 1 back signed!! Thank You Mr. Manning!! 
Bullspulls8 12-29-202012-29-2020Pending 01/1Sent Photo $10 Donation and Letter 
BigBill33 12-18-202001-09-2021Success 221/1Sent 1 8x10 photo and 1 letter with questions// Received photo signed in black sharpie, (Questions unanswered) 
Tdogsports 12-10-202001-28-2021Success 491/1Sent picture and donation. My picture came back unsigned but he sent his own signed. And returned my donation. Thanks Mr. Manning
BirdmanantCollect 12-10-202001-04-2021Success 251/1Received Signed Mini Card, Returned 4x6 Photo and 20$ 
mtool 12-08-202002-19-2021Success 731/1signed 1 card 
Sportsjunkie24 12-01-202012-17-2020Success 161/12nd try with donation. Thank you Mr. Manning
aJFKexperience 11-28-202001-09-2021Success 421/1Finally got my Peyton after 4 tries! Pics on my insta @dragicszn 
Pearly39 11-27-202012-21-2020Success 241/11 jersey card $10 // signed card 
tabcollects 11-27-202012-14-2020Success 171/18x10 w/ letter and $10, personalized 
Schmidty548 11-14-202012-01-2020Success 171/1Provided his own 8x10 w/ $20 donation
GriffeyOverBonds 10-31-202011-13-2020Success 131/08x10 with letter and donation - Sent Back his own 8x10 and returned my letter. Thanks! 
SpartyBall 10-29-202011-21-2020Success 231/1$10 Donation - Update: Card (2000 Topps Gallery) returned signed! 
RileyL3 10-22-202011-21-2020Success 301/1Thanks Mr. Manning! 
Say10man 10-22-202011-27-2020Success 361/1Sent 1 card with pre paid return envelop and written letter //// AWESOME GOT BACK SIGNED 
jeff1981ny 10-10-202011-14-2020Success 351/11 Mossic 
coreysullivan33 10-09-2020 Pending -1/0LOR and 8x10 sent 
Yankeenate 10-05-2020 Pending -1/0  
TribeFan83 10-03-202010-26-2020Success 231/1No card signed, but sent his own 4x6 signed in black, thanks sir! 
mmarq 09-22-202010-19-2020Success 271/12006T, $10 check; per website it says that Peyton will only sign ONE item. 
Abneric 09-14-202010-03-2020Success 192/1didnt sign index, sent his own signed small photo!!! 
jedistiles 09-14-202010-19-2020Success 352/1Signed '15 Topps in black. Thanks Mr. Manning! $10 per card. 
JPSD16 08-31-202003-01-2021Failure 1821/01 card, LOR, SASE/ RTS 
FlyOrDieGuy1992 08-27-202009-24-2020Success 281/1$20 donation,returned my card unsigned but sent a signed 4x6 photo ! 
reesen 08-15-202009-05-2020Success 211/1sent 1 card, requested an 8x10, $20 to PF - recd signed Tenn 8x10 as requested! Unsigned card sent back 
dnahar 08-14-2020 Failure -1/0LOR, SASE, 8X10, $10 donation 
Piester 08-10-202009-15-2020Success 361/1  
gbly22 08-10-2020 Pending -1/0Sent 1 card + $10 Donation 
Sjuschmitty 08-10-202010-01-2020Success 521/11 signed card with $20 donation. 
tpgriffin8112 08-01-202008-30-2020Success 291/1Included $10. Please check out my Instagram page @ttmpete 
Zoofly23 07-31-202009-15-2020Success 461/1Sent 1 and $20- 
  Edit your submission Guest 07-31-2020 Pending -2/0(2) Football Cards - ($20 Donation) 
HalosFan2002 07-30-202001-11-2021Success 1652/12005 Topps Turn Back the Clock and 2017 Score Signal Callers + $5, signed the signal callers, returned the other unsigned. 
EKritzell 07-30-2020 Pending -1/0Sent one 2011 Absolute 
Supup 07-27-202008-13-2020Success 171/1Signed in black; + $5 
tpgriffin8112 07-27-202008-30-2020Success 341/1Sent $10 and card. Received card back signed 
thorgy213 07-24-202008-24-2020Success 311/107 score returned nicely signed. GREAT RETURN!! 
Davidortiz29 07-19-202008-13-2020Success 251/1  
jrosscp 07-16-2020 Pending -1/0Sent 98UD Rookie, $10 donation, note, and SASE. 
Gman05 07-13-2020 Pending -1/0sent colts si, with $5 
Say10man 07-11-202004-01-2022Success 6291/1sent 1 card with written note and pre paid return 
norse4 07-09-202010-19-2020Success 1021/1Sent 1 card, SASE, and LOR/ received card back signed! Didn’t expect to see this one back! ttm_bros on Instagram 
TheCajunCollected 07-08-2020 Pending -1/02015 topps valor 
whitemamba 07-06-2020 Failure -1/0sent one colts and one broncos card with handwritten note:W/O 
Zsnyder1985 07-02-202007-24-2020Success 221/18x10+donation
jeff1981ny 07-01-2020 Failure -1/0Rts 
Jacobdanielsyt 07-01-2020 Pending -1/01 2016 Donruss numbered to 100 
wongcastle 06-30-202007-28-2020Success 281/1sent and received signed 2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock #5
Bimmerboy137 06-29-2020 Pending -1/0LOR, SASE, Card 
jdresbach 06-25-2020 Pending -1/0$10 donation 
King Klong 06-25-2020 Pending -1/01 card. $ 
Justin Vasquez 06-23-202007-31-2020Success 381/1Signed my Legacy Legends Card! Sweet!
Chooch08 06-22-202008-01-2020Success 401/1  
Leeburtt 06-22-202007-20-2020Success 281/1$10 check 
bdye9 06-18-202007-29-2020Success 411/1  
mazefan72 06-15-202007-27-2020Success 421/1Signed 1 card w/donation.TY. NICE! 
TheCajunCollected 06-08-202007-28-2020Success 501/12nd success)reflections in time in blue....now off to Archie 
Braveheart30 05-29-202006-18-2020Success 202/2I wasnt expecting a quick return like this. Signed 5 X 7 photo. With a $10 donation. 
Wolverine 05-29-202006-22-2020Success 241/1Sent LOR, SASE and one card. Returned signed in black, some smearing, but still really cool!
wongcastle 05-26-202006-24-2020Success 291/1sent and received signed 2005 Topps #203
kurtkurtkurtalan 05-25-2020 Pending -1/0  
gfast12 05-21-202006-18-2020Success 281/2Did not sign my 8x10, but sent his own signed photo. Thanks Mr.Manning 
Bdude 05-20-202006-22-2020Success 332/2Signed 2/2 
jjhancock 05-15-2020 Pending -1/0  
kellykruse23 05-12-2020 Pending -1/01 super bowl legends 
mbell 05-07-202005-26-2020Success 191/18x10, SASE, $10 donation. Sent his own signed photo instead. 
Falzone829 05-05-202006-22-2020Success 481/1Thanks again Peyton !!
Zsnyder1985 05-04-202006-20-2020Success 471/01 card
GoWarrior 05-04-202006-23-2020Success 501/1Sending one card and $5. Signed in blue! Last name smudged a bit but I’m still thrilled to get Peyton.
StayFreaky 05-04-202006-20-2020Success 471/11 Card signed in blue. Thanks Mr Manning! StayFreaky34 on Instagram for pics 
MadCityCards 05-04-202006-20-2020Success 471/11 card 
bwalt15 05-01-2020 Pending -1/0LOR SASE $5 and Card 
IAK683 05-01-202006-20-2020Success 501/12005T- signed Thanks Mr. Manning 
TheCajunCollected 04-30-202006-20-2020Success 512/1Signed the 2007 ring of honor in blue!!! Got a little smudged tho but it’s great!
ronhudson 04-30-202005-16-2020Success 161/1Did not sign my 4x6 photo but sent a signed 5x7.
Piester 04-29-202006-22-2020Success 541/1  
zshopes28 04-28-202006-22-2020Success 551/1  
jerseyman1992 04-27-2020 Pending -1/0  
Bdude 04-24-202005-07-2020Success 131/0  
Justin Vasquez 04-23-202005-11-2020Success 182/1Sent 2 8x10 Signed 1 and returned 1. No donation, Thanks Peyton! 
thorgy213 04-23-202009-09-2020Success 1391/1SASE-NOTE-DONATION-04 topps-returned nicely signed 
spikeowen 04-21-202005-15-2020Success 241/001T Hobby Masters insert - signed beautifully in blue! 
Carney 04-15-202006-20-2020Success 661/1  
dish142002 04-13-202006-22-2020Success 701/1Signed 1 card with $10 
JeffFMcCormack 04-13-202006-23-2020Success 711/1I sent a 2015 Topps Fantasy Focus card. Amazing success!!
PRozay24 04-11-202006-22-2020Success 721/1  
alabamagator925 04-10-202007-04-2020Success 851/1Signed 2009 Philadelphia with $20 cash. Exciting return!! 
spikeowen 04-06-202004-20-2020Success 141/12018 Elite Face to Face w/ Eli (already signed by Eli) - Signed it, looks sweet! Thank you Peyton
RIFF RAFF 77 04-06-202009-23-2020Failure 1701/0Write off 
PhilZee93 04-03-202006-03-2020Success 611/21 8x10 - sent back mine unsigned, included another 8x10 signed. Thanks, Mr. Manning!
Craiggb 03-17-202006-11-2022Failure 8161/0Cj 
pmc14 03-13-202001-13-2023Failure 10361/0WRITE OFF 
mrtrhl13 03-05-202004-22-2020Success 471/1** 4th ** HWLOR, SASE, 1 card, no $. Returned signed.
Chooch08 02-26-202003-31-2020Success 331/114 Bowman Chrome, no $ 
kellykruse23 02-26-202004-03-2020Success 361/1Amazing return!!! Thanks Peyton! 1 2015 Heritage card
NickBosa97 02-25-202003-31-2020Success 341/1Signed! 1st Try!!!!! 
csieg 02-21-202004-03-2020Success 411/1  
geomon 02-15-202004-03-2020Success 471/0Sent LOR and 1 card, no donation. Beautifully signed in blue.
McFreddieMercury 02-14-202003-12-2020Success 261/1Success! Said this is the last batch he's signing and he's done :(
Davidortiz29 02-14-202004-20-2020Success 651/1  
Falzone829 02-10-202004-20-2020Success 692/1Signed 1 of 2, signed the Chrome card, thanks Peyton !!!
StarrsCards 02-08-202002-25-2020Failure 171/0RTS. Guess he only signs once per address. 
bigd8690 02-06-202002-26-2020Success 201/1Sent an 8x10. Sent back my photo but sent his own signed photo! 
pmc14 02-04-202003-02-2020Failure 271/0RTS 
dct0824 02-04-202004-20-2020Success 751/1Included a $5 donation. Returned beautifully!! 
mrtrhl13 01-27-202002-11-2020Failure 151/0** 4th ** HWLOR, SASE, 1 card, no $. RTS. Not sure why after several successes here. 
aeich11 01-24-202002-24-2020Success 311/13rd times a charm. Had to use my wifes name this time to finally get my card signed. GREAT return from the now unreliable GOAT!
Craiggb 01-22-202002-24-2020Success 331/1  
grassstain41 01-21-202002-14-2020Failure 241/11st try: Fail, returned TC in SASE unsigned. 2nd try (w/$10 donation): Fail, returned photo in SASE unsigned and took cash. 3rd try: Refused. RTS. Fail. 
Nicolas99 01-20-202002-11-2020Success 221/1  
McFreddieMercury 01-18-202003-26-2020Failure 671/1RTS Write Off 
Chooch08 01-18-202002-24-2020Success 371/105D, no donation 
CarlosSchwindt 01-16-202001-27-2020Success 111/1Sent LOR, SASE, and 8x10 photo, no money. Didn't sign my own, but included and signed his own. 
Gatorfan526 01-16-202001-29-2020Failure 131/0Card, LOR, and SASE + $5 
mrtrhl13 01-11-202002-24-2020Success 441/1** 3rd ** HWLOR, SASE, 1 card, no $. Returned signed.
McFreddieMercury 01-10-202001-17-2020Failure 71/0RTS Write Off 
Piester 01-08-202002-24-2020Success 471/1  
Tomasek 12-30-201901-16-2020Success 171/1Got back signed 5x7 photo signed in black 
aeich11 12-30-201901-23-2020Failure 241/1RTS. ** someone opened it, took the donation & SASE, then RTS my card in original envelope.. very odd 
kandiclipper 12-27-201901-16-2020Success 201/1  
Achilles106 12-20-201901-16-2020Success 271/2Didn't sign my "Season ticket" Tennessee card, but included a 4x6 card signed. What a return from one of the GOATS! THANK YOU MR MANNING! No $ sent
Craiggb 12-20-201901-16-2020Success 271/1  
csieg 12-18-201902-01-2020Success 452/1signed one and one returned unsigned 
reachrulz 12-10-201901-21-2020Success 421/1Received my RC signed today in black marker! // $5 donation sent 
mrtrhl13 12-07-201901-16-2020Success 401/1** 2nd ** TLOR, TSASE, TPWE 1 card, $5. Returned signed.
aeich11 12-05-201912-16-2019Failure 111/1Returned RC unsigned. included signed 4x6. Failure bc he kept my $18 donation. Unreal. Does he not sign rookies?
mrtrhl13 12-03-201912-23-2019Success 201/1HWLOR, SASE, 1 card, no $. Returned signed. Success!
MadTownCards 12-03-201912-13-2019Success 101/1Got signed 4x6 with my unsigned card back 
218cards 12-03-201912-23-2019Success 201/1Sent a 2015 Score, a SASE, and a LOR. Returned signed in black with a few small breaks in the autograph. Still an awesome success from one of the best to ever do it! 
kandiclipper 11-30-201912-13-2019Failure 131/0Returned card unsigned 
Gatorfan526 11-14-201912-19-2019Failure 352/0Card, LOR, and SASE + $5 dono - RTS 
Braveheart30 11-11-201911-21-2019Success 101/1  
PokeyTheBrave 11-04-201912-02-2019Success 281/2Sent playing card - received card back inscribed and signed, as well as photo also inscribed and signed
locly 10-23-201911-29-2019Success 371/1  
kandiclipper 10-15-201911-29-2019Success 451/1Huge return today! Signed in black! 
zonino 10-08-201912-03-2019Success 562/1  
qbdan14 10-07-201912-10-2019Failure 641/1Yet another Failure, no note or anything just everything back, very sad 
Gatorfan526 09-20-201910-09-2019Success 192/1trying again, sent $5 dono and 2 cards. Recieved 1 of 2 cards back, super happy! 
cardsbaseball245 09-14-201910-07-2019Success 231/1WOW!! Signed my card in blue sharpie with NO donation! SASE and LOR. Thank you so much Mr. Manning! 
jplcom 09-09-201909-28-2019Failure 191/1Sent 1 1999 Finest, Letter, SASE, and $20 donation. Sent back check @ card in my SASE. 
Danmay55 08-26-201910-07-2019Success 421/1W $5 sent back signed! 
Craiggb 08-09-201908-29-2019Failure 201/0Rts 
cameronkirwan03 08-04-201908-28-2019Failure 241/1Sent a 4x6, really hoping for this back, RTS, Unable to forward. Will try again 
TNenforcer 07-22-201908-26-2019Success 351/1Sent LOR, SASE, 1 card, and a $5 donation - Recieved card back signed.
BurkerKing 07-16-201908-03-2019Failure 182/2Sent 2 cards (1 Broncos, 1 Tennessee). RTS again (Was a success 1st time, then 2 rts’s). Addressed to “Peyback Foundation c/o Peyton Manning” this time. Last time was 
Donhutson 07-13-2019 Pending -1/0  
nobzilla34 07-11-201908-19-2019Failure 391/1Sent w/ Donation/RTS 
noshi0085 06-29-2019 Pending -1/01 card 
Zrianna08 06-24-2019 Pending -2/0  
BurkerKing 06-24-201907-13-2019Failure 192/02nd letter sent. 1st was a success of 2 cards. Sent 2 different ones now a RTS! I don’t get it. 
nobzilla34 06-11-201907-01-2019Failure 201/1Sent w/ Donation/RTS 
Moxieh 05-22-201907-08-2019Success 471/1I love it. Thank you Peyton Manning. 
zbullsmoke 05-21-201906-14-2019Success 242/3sent 2 customs and donation. returned customs unsigned but returned a card of his own signed and personalized to me. thanks mr. manning! 
Gatorfan526 05-16-201909-16-2019Failure 1232/0No return, attempting again. 
BurkerKing 05-13-201906-14-2019Success 322/2Make out to Peyback Foundation. I did not include a donation. Signed 2/2 cards (1 Colts/ 1 Pro Bowl)!
Tbird21 05-08-2019 Pending -1/0  
nobzilla34 05-06-201905-28-2019Success 221/1Kind of a success. Didn't sign my item, but sent back a signed photo of his own. 
Bdude 05-02-201905-25-2019Success 231/1Send 1 card signed it in blue 
mlbfan74 04-24-201905-24-2019Success 301/1Signed card! Sent hand written Letter, $5, and 1 card. Beautifully signed. 
Wellsalex18 04-16-201905-03-2019Success 171/1Sent $5 donation and letter 
Gatorfan526 04-16-201905-01-2019Failure 151/0LOR, trading card and return postage + $5 donation - guess he doesn't sign jersey cards. Resending a different card. 
Leeburtt 04-11-201905-03-2019Success 221/1$10 check 
pokemonclub 04-10-201905-03-2019Success 231/1  
Biggums7 03-25-201904-18-2019Failure 241/1  
bobby1134 03-20-201904-19-2019Failure 301/0RTS 
Wildcat6812 03-15-201904-08-2019Success 241/1Returned card unsigned, but sent a signed picture 
HouseOfCards 03-11-201903-23-2019Success 121/11 2018 Classic in blue Sharpie 
RIFF RAFF 77 03-04-201903-22-2019Success 171/1W/ $5 donation 
evoniukus 03-01-201904-09-2019Success 381/1Sent 1 card, LOR, SASE and $10 donation. Returned signed in Blue Sharpie. Awesome!!
jplcom 02-27-201904-06-2019Success 372/1Sent 2 1999 Finest, Letter, SASE, and $40 donation. Received both cards back, one autographed. Thanks Mr Manning!
pokemonclub 02-27-201903-29-2019Success 291/1  
SyxxSynse 02-16-201905-03-2019Success 751/1Signed my 2013 Panini Contenders Season Ticket card. $5 donation. Thanks, Mr. Manning! 
JayHo7284 02-15-201904-08-2019Failure 511/0RTS - Unclaimed 
dish142002 02-08-201902-25-2019Success 171/1Signed 1 card with $10! 
Craiggb 02-07-201902-25-2019Success 181/1Cj 
Jhcutt 01-30-2019 Pending -2/0Sent LOR/SASE/2 cards + $20 donation (check) 
pokemonclub 01-30-201902-20-2019Failure 211/0Returned unsigned, saying he can't sign rookies 
21kholley 01-22-201902-15-2019Success 241/1Signed 2010 Topps w/ 5$ Donation! 
Clevey48 01-16-201902-04-2019Success 192/1SASE 
JayHo7284 01-12-201902-01-2019Failure 201/0RTS - Unclaimed 
Ttmcollector1016 01-07-201902-15-2019Success 391/1Sent card and $5 donation. Sig looks Awesome! 
jmarince 01-02-201902-15-2019Success 441/1Signed Topps Chrome 
chicagobullsjoe 12-28-2018 Pending -1/0Sent 1 Card and $20 
tc123 12-21-201801-11-2019Success 211/1Sent Card 
baseballfan14 12-05-201812-19-2018Failure 141/0Sent my $10 back with the card unsigned 
Smafigus 12-04-201812-19-2018Success 151/1Signed 2013 momentum 
chicagobullsjoe 11-20-201812-22-2018Success 321/1Sent 1 Card, SASE and $20 donation
midnightoyl 11-16-201811-01-2018Success -162/1Received an autographed card. Thank you Mr. Manning. 
jmaciu 11-10-201812-28-2018Success 481/12011T + $20 check to the Peyback Foundation. Signed nicely with black sharpie and inscripted with his number. Very excited to add an autograph of my favorite Colt to my collection. Thank you, Mr. Manning!!!!
steelerfan23 11-03-201812-17-2018Success 441/1Sent 1 from '15 Topps Valor and $5 donation. 
Donhutson 10-22-201811-19-2018Failure 281/0with donation. unsigned and sent donation back 
Logan Richmond 10-22-201811-06-2018Failure 151/02015P +donation **Returned in my SASE... :( ** 
StarrsCards 10-20-201812-17-2018Success 581/1Sent a 2018 Classics and received it back signed in black with “18” inscription. No fee!
mestacio31 10-19-201810-30-2018Success 111/1Sent 8x10, LOR, SASE, and Donation. Returned a signed stock photo and my 8x10 unsigned.
pmc14 10-19-201811-07-2018Failure 191/0Sent back my donation and card unsigned. Used my SASE 
diback34 10-15-2018 Pending -1/01 card and $20 donation 
Biggums7 10-15-201810-29-2018Failure 141/1Received photo unsigned 
pmc14 10-01-201810-15-2018Failure 141/0Sent card back unsigned. I didn’t send a donation. 
hinkema1 09-27-201810-13-2018Success 161/1Sent $15 donation 
Coltron57 09-22-201810-13-2018Success 211/1$5. Signed in blue. 
biggsy2323 09-07-201809-27-2018Success 202/1FINALLY after 5 failures 
bdmorr 08-31-201810-13-2018Success 431/1  
Ky1603 08-28-201810-01-2018Success 341/1W/$20 
Natecool00 08-20-201809-07-2018Success 182/0sent 2 cards and $20 donation great to get back! 
BDS 07-31-201809-10-2018Success 411/1Signed 2016 Panini Score in black - thanks PM! 
lh4augie 07-13-201808-25-2018Failure 431/1Returned my photo unsigned 
Catman 07-05-201812-14-2018Success 1622/1Sent a $20 donation 
cameronkirwan03 06-16-201809-21-2018Success 971/1Sent a '13 Score Salute to Service card, hoping for better luck. Came back signed in black inscribed with 
Donhutson 06-04-201807-23-2018Failure 491/0rts 
chicagobullsjoe 05-31-201808-24-2018Failure 851/0Sent 1 Card and SASE. Refused 
Piester 05-22-201808-20-2018Success 901/1  
diback34 05-21-2018 Pending -1/0sending 1 card and donation 
yankeegiant13 05-19-201806-02-2018Success 142/02 4x6 returned unsigned. Sent custom signed card back instead. May be real 
qbdan14 05-14-201806-07-2018Failure 241/1Sent card and $5, came back unsigned and kept my money. Too many failures from him 
chicagobullsjoe 05-14-201807-09-2018Success 561/1Set 1 Card and SASE
aqscards 05-05-201806-01-2018Failure 272/2$5 
BayAreaJavy 05-04-201805-11-2018Success 71/1Received print not sure if autopen or real 
bdmorr 05-04-201805-25-2018Failure 211/0card came back unsigned 
baseballfan14 04-21-201805-24-2018Success 331/1Absolutely stunned. Signed my 2016 panini classics in black. THanks Peyton 
DC4L 04-16-201805-12-2018Failure 261/1Sent money and card back, guess he was too busy. 
DC4L 04-16-201805-29-2018Success 431/1Sent 2010 Topps MVP card and it came back signed in black sharpie! Super excited to get this one back! Thanks Mr. Manning! 
broncosfan2 04-16-201805-26-2018Success 401/1Really hope this is a success!...... Came back signed!!! Mojo! 
NegleyPirate 04-05-201804-20-2018Success 151/0Sent custom signed print
Itsthejw 04-04-201805-31-2018Success 571/1Card came back signed, enclosed letter, SASE and $10 donation 
Datboijohnny 03-23-201804-14-2018Success 221/1Sent $5 and 2010 sp authentic. Got back today signed in black. Thank you! 
Rockiesfan13 03-14-201804-13-2018Success 301/1Signed in black with $5 donation 
SyxxSynse 03-12-201804-07-2018Failure 261/0RTS/Refused 
DC4L 03-07-201804-14-2018Success 372/2Sent 2 cards with donation. Received both cards back but, only one was signed. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
Figman75 03-06-201804-14-2018Success 381/1Signed 2017 Classic in black. Thank you! 
cameronkirwan03 03-06-201804-04-2018Failure 281/0Sent a '17 Donruss base card, Return To Sender, unable to deliver as addressed. Will try again. 
bigcountry 03-05-201804-13-2018Success 381/1Signed card w/$5 donation. 
Miller54 03-03-201804-13-2018Success 402/1Sent card with question on index card. Signed card, no index. 
Jjefkins6 02-27-201803-26-2018Success 261/1sent w/ $10 donation. Returned 4x6 unsigned. Included 3x5 picture signed. Still cool. 
bdmorr 02-26-201803-27-2018Failure 281/0RTS 
ttmracker 02-16-201803-19-2018Failure 301/0Sent an 11x14 with donation. Refused RTS. 
jimmyf21 02-06-201803-10-2018Success 321/1mailed 1 card and sase - received card signed in black 
Jdscards0323 02-03-201802-27-2018Success 241/0Sent a broncos card and 5$. Received it back signed in black 
BugeaterBaseball 01-30-201802-26-2018Success 271/1Sent $10 donation for 1 Broncos card./Signed in black sharpie 
baseballfan14 01-24-201802-28-2018Success 351/1$5 donation sent. Signed my card when he joined the 4000 yard club. Thanks Peyton 
Logan Richmond 01-17-201803-01-2018Failure 431/02013 Topps Mini +$5 **RTS- Refused** 
jberg 01-05-201801-30-2018Success 251/1$5- 98Topps/ signed in black #18 
LARams 01-04-201801-27-2018Success 231/11/1 signed and included note card with his foundation's info. To see my other successes, check out gridironshowcase.weebly.com 
Donhutson 01-04-201801-20-2018Failure 161/0unsigned 
Meatballer23 01-02-201801-26-2018Success 241/1Signed 2014 Topps NFL MVP card and added #18. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
bdmorr 12-29-201701-29-2018Failure 311/0RTS 
JeffFMcCormack 12-29-201707-11-2025Failure 27501/0I sent a 1999 Upper Deck MVP card, $5, letter, and SASE. Write off. 
puck34 12-29-201701-24-2018Failure 261/0Sent 1 card along with $5/ RTS UTF 
LSwens 12-26-201701-26-2018Success 311/1Sent one card... Received signed nicely in black sharpie with number. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
Andrew915 12-22-201701-26-2018Success 351/1$5 donation/Signed 2015 topps in black! sweet return 
zjlwolves3 12-18-201701-11-2018Success 241/1My CD card cracked, so they sent a pre-signed picture -- https://imgur.com/GVnQ674 
aqscards 12-16-201701-26-2018Success 411/1  
vagrapher 12-10-201701-19-2018Success 401/1Signed in black totally stoked 
jimmyf21 12-09-201712-23-2017Success 142/1mailed 2 cards and sase - received 1 card signed in black and 1 card unsigned 
qbdan14 12-05-201701-17-2018Failure 431/1Back unsigned again no note 
TripleTTyler50 12-04-201712-28-2017Success 241/1Sent 1 Donruss Colts card received back signed in black sharpie 
qbdan14 11-14-201712-28-2017Failure 441/1Sent 1 photo, back unsigned, no note 
bigcountry 11-13-201712-29-2017Success 461/1  
qman130 11-11-201712-23-2017Success 421/0Sent one football card and a donation 
ClevelandSports 11-04-201712-11-2017Success 371/1'06 Rookies and Stars in 37 days! I can't believe I've gotten 2 in a row! 
Yanksfan876 10-20-201711-13-2017Success 241/1Signed in black sharpie! Big success!
jreaven 10-09-201710-10-2017Success 13/1sent 3 cards and one were i am hoping to get marvin harrison,peyton manning,and edgiran james and 5 donation 
Striker83 10-02-201710-20-2017Success 181/1Sent LOR, SASE, 8X10, and donation/Received my photo back unsigned, however included 8x10 signed in black sharpie.
twinsfan83 09-27-201711-13-2017Success 471/1$5 donation, UD Choice RC 
RobHarrington 08-25-201709-25-2017Success 311/12014 Topps Prime signed in black ink. 
diback34 07-19-2017 Pending -1/0  
Redskins2124 07-11-201708-11-2017Success 313/1Envelope stamped from this address by the Peyback Foundation. Signed one in Blue! Awesome! 
jbcards 06-22-201707-22-2017Success 301/1Boom! 2 for 2 sending to Mr. Manning, sent a small donation as well. 2015 topps fantasy focus signed in black, took exactly a month.
stealthywizard00 06-19-2017 Pending -1/0Sent 1 card, LOR, and SASE 
Donhutson 06-06-201705-25-2018Failure 3531/0returned unsigned 
nfonzi 05-25-201707-23-2017Success 591/1sent card with $5 cash donation 
ClevelandSports 05-18-201706-15-2017Success 281/12016 Donruss (2003 'The Sheriff' version) Really hope I get this one back! 28 days! Signed in blue! A little smudged AND it has a fingerprint on it lol. Does that make it more valuable? 
skinsfan832 05-17-201706-17-2017Success 311/1I can't believe I got it back! Signed ’09 Playoff Prestige card, thank you Mr. Manning!!!! 
spikeowen 05-17-201707-04-2017Success 481/298 Flair rc row 1 - Signed card, was smudged, sent an additional card and a note apologizing to me for the smudge, Mr. Manning is too kind. I love this guy! 
Fastball627 04-05-201704-17-2017Success 121/1Sent index card, returned his own 3x2 pitcure signed 
Scaarps81 04-05-201705-15-2017Success 401/1Topps Heritage - My best return yet! 
Ryanmillerfan30 03-30-201705-12-2017Failure 431/0RTS Refused, ugh Peyton you're killing me man! 
SyxxSynse 03-29-201705-15-2017Success 471/1Signed my 2015 Panini card. 47 days. Thanks, Mr. Manning! 
Batting gloves88 03-18-2017 Pending -1/0Sent 1 card SASE, Letter 
BoSoxFan4235 03-11-201704-28-2017Success 471/1Signed 1 card in black 
Mitchell2314 03-10-201703-27-2017Success 161/1Sent 1 card. (1-2012 Panini) Signed in black sharpie! 
kactusjakk 02-16-201703-23-2017Success 341/1Sent jersey #, LOR, SASE and donation - amazing success 
LiutenantVan 01-26-201703-06-2017Success 391/1Sent 2012T w/ letter and $10 check donation...Signed in blue but auto a little smudged and card is dinged up. I'M HAPPY!!! 
TalleyHog34 01-19-201702-03-2017Success 151/1Sent mini UT helmet, LOR, SASE, black sharpie and donation. Kind of a success. Didn't sign helmet but got his signature on a crumpled up piece of cardboard. 
CHeck301 01-18-201702-10-2017Success 231/1sent a card for him to sign; didn't sign but sent his own card signed
EKritzell 01-17-201702-04-2017Failure 181/1Sent 1 card. Returned unsigned with a preprint 
JeffFMcCormack 01-16-201703-15-2019Success 7871/0I sent a 2015 Panini-Donruss Card, handwritten letter, $5, and SASE. Success! 
Mike McK 01-12-201703-03-2017Success 501/1  
eaglesrock55 01-12-201703-06-2017Success 532/1  
qbdan14 01-08-201702-07-2017Failure 301/0Received my photo back unsigned, no note or anything describing why 
Ryanmillerfan30 01-03-201701-20-2017Failure 171/0  
Tombrady123 12-27-201601-09-2017Success 132/1  
akenny 12-25-201601-09-2017Success 151/1Sent 1 card with letter, returned 1 card signed with slip of paper saying why you should donate to St. Vincent Childrans Hospital. 
jbcards 12-23-201601-09-2017Success 171/1Sent '16 Score card and a donation... wrote 'DONATION ENCLOSED' in big letters on the front... CAME BACK SIGNED! Thank you Mr. Manning!
totalnv 12-22-201601-09-2017Success 181/1SASE, LOR, 1 trading card - signed card in blue sharpie
Donhutson 12-20-201603-05-2017Success 752/1Sent 2 cards and questions. signed card but got kinda smugded 
Atlantaman 12-19-201601-11-2017Success 232/1  
BoSoxFan4235 12-17-201612-31-2016Failure 141/0Sending 1 card. No luck, came back unsigned in my SASE 
yankeesgiants2000 12-16-201601-12-2017Success 271/1Sent $5 donation! Super happy about this success!!! Only took 27 days 
JayHo7284 12-09-201601-09-2017Failure 311/0  
NolansCards 11-28-201612-16-2016Success 181/1Sent Fantasy Studs card and recieved it back signed. Thanks Mr. Manning! 
NolansCards 11-28-201612-16-2016Success 181/1 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 0%    
Total number of submission on this address: 1
# of Success: 0  # of Failed: 0  # of Pending: 1
Instruction:
Added by:dadrock   Added on: 06-14-2017
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
MisterE 11-10-2017 Pending -1/0Crossing fingers I sent a foot ball card and letter and $2 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 0%    
Total number of submission on this address: 3
# of Success: 0  # of Failed: 3  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:
Added by:Tombrady123   Added on: 02-08-2021
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
rggedglory 09-09-202112-14-2021Failure 962/22 cards; update RTS 
rggedglory 09-09-202112-13-2021Failure 952/22 cards; update RTS 
mtool 07-11-202112-10-2021Failure 1521/0return to sender 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 0%    
Total number of submission on this address: 3
# of Success: 0  # of Failed: 1  # of Pending: 2
Instruction:c/o The Peyback Foundation
Added by:crupe29   Added on: 08-01-2022
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
krazykid112 01-10-2023 Pending -1/0sent rookie card 
rggedglory 09-16-2022 Failure -1/01 card; CALLING THIS A FAIL 
crupe29 08-01-2022 Pending -1/0Sent one 8x10 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 0%    
Total number of submission on this address: 1
# of Success: 0  # of Failed: 1  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:
Added by:BruceyBoy   Added on: 03-03-2024
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
ODM 04-28-202505-11-2025Failure 131/0Sent 1 card, also put in a $1 dono 
 



TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25

TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25

Latest TTM Successes

Led ZeppTim just received this TTM autograph item from the player Rick Rhoden timblack just received this TTM autograph item from the player Don Strock Gyroman66 just received this TTM autograph item from the player Tyler Kolek (NBA) TopherVT just received this TTM autograph item from the player Bobby Valentine Falzone829 just received this TTM autograph item from the player Dan Fouts Falzone829 just received this TTM autograph item from the player Juan Gonzalez

Trough The Mail Manager



Upcoming Cards Show


2026-07-18 : Huntington Card Show
2026-07-18 : Florence Card Fest
2026-07-19 : The Tampa Bay Sports Card Show
2026-07-29 : The 46th National Sports Collectors Convention
2026-07-30 : The 46th National Sports Collectors Convention

Cards Show Calendar



×

About SCF

Sports Card Forum provides sports and non-sports card collectors a safe place to discuss, buy, sell and trade.

SCF maintains tools that will allow collectors to manage their collections online, information about what is happening with the hobby, as well as providing robust data to send out for Autographs through the mail.

Tools and Forums

Sponsors

Follow SCF on