TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25


    First name:    Last name:    Sport:    

Gary Plummer Addresses Report   Sport: Football

Player overall success: 98%



Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 98%    
Total number of submission on this address: 130
# of Success: 104  # of Failed: 2  # of Pending: 24
Instruction:
Added by:indyreds   Added on: 01-03-2010
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
MRICHARDSON1977 06-01-2026 Pending -1/090 Pro Set, no fee 
txrangerscollect 04-10-202604-20-2026Success 102/22 cards and questions 
jeffrice80 03-06-2026 Pending -1/01991 Upper Deck #575 
Hornets99 02-07-2026 Pending -2/0  
Ricochet 01-09-2026 Pending -1/091 Pacific, HWLOR 
Havok 01-05-2026 Pending -2/01990 Pro Set & 1992 GameDay 
rich summa 12-01-2025 Pending -1/090 Topps Tiffany 
Danmay55 10-14-2025 Pending -1/0  
rggedglory 10-06-2025 Pending -1/0* 
bigd8690 09-11-202509-26-2025Success 153/3Sent 3 cards. Received signed 
rggedglory 08-02-2025 Pending -1/0* 
autographs2010 07-17-2025 Pending -3/0  
jdresbach 07-05-2025 Pending -1/01990 Pro Set 
Purnell 06-30-2025 Pending -1/0card letter sase 
card openings 06-18-2025 Pending -1/091 pro set 
mbcooke13 06-10-2025 Pending -2/0Cards, SASE, Typed Letter 
NCoop08 05-21-202505-31-2025Success 103/3Sent SASE, letter, 91 Fleer and 2 3x5 index cards - Update: returned all items signed! Thanks!
Ryno8383 05-12-2025 Pending -2/0no fee 
Pearly1 05-12-2025 Pending -2/02 cards + HR note + SASE 
Sweetbob 05-12-2025 Pending -2/091UD - 91PL - SASE 
rggedglory 05-05-2025 Pending -1/0xxxx 
Stlouisfan 04-30-202502-10-2026Success 2861/1No Fee. SASE. Appreciate it Gary!!
Stigs4 04-23-2025 Pending -1/01990 Pro Set, SASE, HWLOR 
mgrammo 04-12-202504-22-2025Success 102/2Quick response. Nicely signed. 
BigMike070 04-03-202504-22-2025Success 191/1Sent 1 card, a hwlor, and a SASE to Mr. Plummer. Received my card back signed. 
rggedglory 03-19-202509-30-2025Pending 1951/11 card; recent successes posted at www.facebook.com/SportsCardGalleryofArkansas 
egerding 02-06-202503-03-2025Success 252/1HWLOR, SASE, signed one, kept one 
rich summa 01-13-202502-21-2025Success 391/190 Action Packed 
rggedglory 12-07-202404-23-2025Success 1361/11 card; thx new Gasper TTM book on Amazon 
mtool 12-01-202402-21-2025Success 823/2signed 2 
Mets4ever 10-25-202411-12-2024Success 181/1Sent one card SASE and handwritten letter 
jpollard 09-23-202411-04-2024Success 423/3  
Habs Fan 31 09-14-202410-30-2024Success 461/192 AW sports - sase hwlor - in blue 
Tombrady123 09-12-202410-16-2024Success 342/2  
mastil 09-09-202410-29-2024Success 502/0  
702tpr777 08-26-202409-03-2024Success 82/21991 Fleer, 1993 Topps... Thanks Mr. Plummer! 
Hulkrulz 08-17-202410-29-2024Success 733/3Sent 3 cards. Got 3 back that weren't what I sent. 
alabamagator925 07-31-202408-29-2024Success 293/3Amazing return! Signed USFL, 49ers and Chargers cards 
choop3r 06-26-202408-24-2024Success 591/1Signed my card black sharpie, so awesome!
rich summa 06-21-202408-26-2024Success 661/192 Topps 
CamaroDMD 06-13-202408-22-2024Success 703/3Sent 3 Cards, LOR, SASE. All 3 signed! 
Calebssportscards 05-18-202408-24-2024Success 982/2Signed 2 cards// Received date is approximate 
jpollard 05-09-202408-26-2024Success 1095/5  
Dis Guy 04-08-202404-23-2024Success 154/391 SC, 91 Portraits, and custom card. Check out my successes at https://www.youtube.com/@disguyscards4445/videos 
Habs Fan 31 03-16-202404-22-2024Success 372/291 topps, 92 stadium club - sase hwlor - both in black 
Steviessportscard 02-23-202403-25-2024Success 301/1Sent a letter, one card and a SASE. 
Stebbins25 02-15-202403-20-2024Success 332/2See My Returns On YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_3LfyaGrNGUluOY1y5VqOg 
JMic91 02-12-202403-25-2024Success 413/23 cards sent. 2 signed and returned. 
jimrice1978 02-03-202403-25-2024Success 501/291 Pro Set plus added card 
caguiar33 01-20-202402-09-2024Success 203/3 
Bowler300x2 01-16-202402-12-2024Success 271/192 Pro Set Power Combo
hockeytown 01-16-2024 Pending -4/0  
meatjohnson 01-03-202402-12-2024Success 404/2  
wischeese 12-21-202301-13-2024Success 232/290T 91T 
jdresbach 12-11-202301-13-2024Success 331/11992 Score 
jpollard 11-29-202312-09-2023Success 102/2  
mastil 09-02-2023 Pending -4/0  
redfirescorpio 08-08-2023 Failure -1/090 Pro Set; LOR, SASE. Write Off. 
eshelton13 07-14-202309-14-2023Success 623/23 Cards, SASE, and LOR (1 for my neighbor hopefully) 
autographs2010 07-10-202309-12-2023Success 644/3  
Drake00 07-06-2023 Pending -3/03 cards, SASE, letter 
jpollard 07-06-202309-14-2023Success 705/3 
mastil 06-12-202309-18-2023Success 984/4  
jpollard 06-01-202306-20-2023Success 193/3 
timblack 05-01-202306-20-2023Success 501/1Signed the 1989 Topps card I sent! Thank you, Mr. Plummer!
Puckhead239 04-19-202306-21-2023Success 633/3 
mastil 04-10-202306-20-2023Success 715/3  
rich summa 03-28-202306-21-2023Success 851/192 Skybox 
TMW289 01-24-202302-14-2023Success 213/3He signed all three cards with a nice blue thin sharpie. Awesome return. Thanks Gary. 
MEvans 01-14-202302-06-2023Success 231/1I sent a 1984 USFL card and he signed! Thanks Mr. Plummer! 
mastil 11-22-202201-17-2023Success 564/4  
CRM302 11-11-202201-17-2023Success 671/1Sent 1996 Topps. Signed in black sharpie. Thanks Mr. Plummer! 
footballautos 10-22-202211-04-2022Success 132/290 pro set, 91 pacific. Thank you sir! 
allenm1985 10-10-202211-20-2022Success 412/2  
rggedglory 09-24-202201-18-2023Success 1161/11 card 
Grandy15 09-23-202211-10-2022Success 483/3sent LOR, SASE, and 3 cards 
Ky1603 09-02-202211-12-2022Success 711/11996 Topps 
rich summa 08-20-202211-12-2022Success 841/193 Bowman 
mtool 07-27-202208-11-2022Success 153/2signed 2 cards 
rich summa 06-06-202208-09-2022Success 641/192 Pacific 
D.J.Williams55 05-26-202208-09-2022Success 752/21 Custom card, 91 Pacific
amerks22 04-11-202205-12-2022Success 314/42 cards signed in black sharpie, 2 cards signed in blue sharpie 
mtool 03-20-202204-12-2022Success 234/3signed 3 cards 
Vercingetorix 03-10-202204-13-2022Success 331/1Quick Return. great signature 
tilt122 03-02-202204-15-2022Success 431/190PS 
Eagles07 02-04-202204-13-2022Success 671/11990 Fleer. Thanks. 
rich summa 01-31-202204-12-2022Success 701/190 Topps 
capaap 12-29-202101-29-2022Success 311/1 
rggedglory 10-08-202101-28-2022Success 1121/11 card 
rich summa 08-26-202107-07-2022Failure 3152/090 Fleer Update 92 Topps 
JMac25 08-20-202109-09-2021Success 203/3Signed 3/3 in blue. One smeared. 
chef 08-02-202108-23-2021Success 211/1  
rich summa 07-22-202108-21-2021Success 302/291 Ultra 92 Fleer 
EHath2 07-19-202108-24-2021Success 361/1Sent a 91 Fleer Ultra and got it back signed in blue 
RH81 06-03-202106-21-2021Success 184/3Kept 1 double suggested 
Stebbins25 04-16-202104-26-2021Success 103/1See My Returns On YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_3LfyaGrNGUluOY1y5VqOg 
rich summa 02-16-202103-12-2021Success 242/290 Pro Set 91 Pro Set 
Travish33 01-04-202101-29-2021Success 251/191 Proline. SASE. Signed card 
rich summa 12-21-202001-29-2021Success 393/389 Topps 91 Fleer 95 Ultra 
rich summa 12-01-202012-15-2020Success 141/190 Pro Set 
locly 11-03-202012-03-2020Success 302/291 score and 91 pacific,also sent some questions kept the questions 
rich summa 10-16-202011-21-2020Success 361/192 Gameday 
rich summa 09-04-202009-15-2020Success 111/191 Fleer 
Jbutch20 08-15-202008-25-2020Success 101/1  
crbaughn62 06-26-202002-22-2021Success 2413/3No inscription 
sydbarrett3177 05-30-202006-06-2020Success 73/31989 topps, 1991 score, 1990 topps 
bzap62 05-13-202005-21-2020Success 81/1Signed my card in black sharpie, also sent a nice note back. 
rich summa 05-01-202005-09-2020Success 81/191 Score 
pbtank67 02-03-202002-11-2020Success 81/190PS. Nicely signed in blue sharpie. 
bhays44 01-03-202001-10-2020Success 73/3LOR, SASE, signed all 3. Thanks!
mnbigfoot 01-02-202001-11-2020Success 92/2(2) 1990 Pro Set. Thanks Mr. Plummer!
Snapper06 12-02-201902-25-2020Success 851/1  
fettjade 10-22-201910-29-2019Success 73/3Signed all 3 cards in blank sharpie. Super fast return.
Panthermatt 09-04-201909-14-2019Success 101/1Sent a 1991 Pacific football card. Received the card back signed. Thanks Mr. Plummer! 
RedskinRussell 07-31-201908-09-2019Success 92/2Signed 91 Pacific, 93 Topps and answered questions 
Patgrealish 07-31-201908-09-2019Success 91/1SASE. 90 Topps 
BraveStarr 07-13-201907-20-2019Success 72/2'90 Pro Set, '91 Bowman - http://bravestarrcards.com 
Robcleveland3 07-03-201907-12-2019Success 91/1Returned the wrong card, but at least I got one back 
Craiggb 07-02-201907-12-2019Success 103/2  
Phinsman 06-01-201906-08-2019Success 73/3Great signature on all three, two were personalized to my sons including #50 
Vick1jj 03-16-201903-25-2019Success 94/3Sent LOR, SASE, and 4 cards, he sent back 3 signed and kept 1, the cards he signed were a 1991 Fleer, a 1991 Topps, and a 1991 Pinnacle, all were in blue sharpie with #50 inscribed 
Calebssportscards 03-09-201903-18-2019Success 83/4cards signed
Craiggb 01-16-201901-31-2019Success 155/5  
Craiggb 11-02-201811-19-2018Success 175/5  
HouseOfCards 03-05-201803-13-2018Success 72/21 Topps and 1 Pro Set both in black 
JesseWaller 02-27-201803-12-2018Pending 121/1Sent LOR, SASE, and 1 card, returned the card signed. Thanks Gary! 
delones24 05-09-201703-01-2018Success 2962/289 Topps x2
Calebssportscards 04-08-201702-27-2018Success 3252/22 cards signed
heffyscards 12-30-201601-09-2017Success 103/2Signed 2 cards ,kept 1 ,Thanks Gary! 
jrheffy 09-04-201609-13-2016Success 92/2signed 2 cards Thanks Gary 
Address
  
   Only registered members on SCF forum can view addresses
and use the TTMM application to track what they sent!

Address success percentage: 100%    
Total number of submission on this address: 17
# of Success: 17  # of Failed: 0  # of Pending: 0
Instruction:
Added by:REDANDGOLDPRIDE   Added on: 05-23-2010
 
  
NameDate MailedDate ReceivedStatusDaysRatioCommentImage
Sc77 01-12-202001-18-2020Success 61/1  
RIFF RAFF 77 01-12-201901-18-2019Success 62/2Signed both cards and sent note. Thanks Gary 
Patgrealish 12-26-201801-07-2019Success 121/1SASE 92 Topps Gold 
Craiggb 11-30-201812-10-2018Success 106/4  
Provo986 01-25-201802-03-2018Success 91/1  
Wyattket88 12-11-201702-27-2018Success 782/2He signed 2 cards in blue 
chazeroom 11-03-201712-04-2017Success 313/3  
grantbojang1 01-03-201701-09-2017Success 61/1Signed my card in Black Sharpie! Also wrote on my handwritten note thanking me for my letter. Thanks Gary! Follow my Instagram to stay up to date with my latest TTMs: https://www.instagram.com/ttm_derek/ 
bmatz23 12-21-201601-07-2017Success 173/3  
nfllivewire 02-02-201402-10-2014Success 83/38 days signed all 3 cards 
padsdsu 01-06-201401-18-2014Success 123/3x3 signed in blue sharpie 
JoFo1116 03-09-201309-27-2013Success 2011/1signed my 1991 Pacific 
turbo49er 08-09-201201-26-2013Success 1701/1Got my signed 49ers 8x10 in the mail today! It took about 5 1/2 months (170 days) but I am happy to see it arrive! He put a really nice long inscription! Signature great! Thanks Gary! 
delones24 05-16-201206-29-2012Success 442/2 
Brandon3737 02-13-201202-21-2012Success 81/1signed card; sent custom letter back too (signed) 
garpike 11-01-201111-12-2011Success 111/1sent LOR, SASE and card...signed card recieved! 
REDANDGOLDPRIDE 06-06-201007-13-2010Success 371/1 
 



TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25

TTMM Menu

Player List Team Fan Pack Recent Successes TTMM Tutorial

TTM Statistics

Members Top 25 Hockey Top 25 Baseball Top 25 Basketball Top 25 Football Top 25 Golf Top 25 Racing Top 25 Other Sport Top 25 Soccer Top 25 Non Sports Top 25

Latest TTM Successes

GeorgiaBulldogs just received this TTM autograph item from the player Donald Trump capaap just received this TTM autograph item from the player Levi Robinson CJamesG just received this TTM autograph item from the player Terry Humphrey TSVarso just received this TTM autograph item from the player Luis Gonzalez TSVarso just received this TTM autograph item from the player Andy Van Slyke Italiarmo just received this TTM autograph item from the player Jim Perry

Trough The Mail Manager



Upcoming Cards Show


2026-07-11 : The FLIP Columbus Georgia
2026-07-11 : Mooresville Summer Show 2026
2026-07-12 : Mooresville Summer Show 2026
2026-07-17 : The Tampa Bay Sports Card Show
2026-07-18 : Huntington Card Show

Cards Show Calendar



×

About SCF

Sports Card Forum provides sports and non-sports card collectors a safe place to discuss, buy, sell and trade.

SCF maintains tools that will allow collectors to manage their collections online, information about what is happening with the hobby, as well as providing robust data to send out for Autographs through the mail.

Tools and Forums

Sponsors

Follow SCF on