should superlative cards be removed??

[seanerster]

Depending on how high-end the card is for me, but what company's like Ultra-Pro should do is create Magnetic Holders that fit Top-loaders inside for Superlative, If they dont sell discontinue the product, just my 2 cents

Very expensive for Ultra-Pro to make that investment. There are relatively few Superlative cards in the market, and the production process for Ultra-Pro can only be efficient with HUGE production runs. This is the exact same reason that Ultra-Pro does not make super thick One-Touches for The Cup Dual Shields. Too few cards, too little demand for a production run.
-Sean

[Prime B]

This topic has been beaten to death.

No doubt. I made my feelings known right off the bat in May when, to the horror of many , I did this with a 1/1.

Go me.


https://www.sportscardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1117908

[habscards]

I think that it lowers the value of the card but I would take it out and put it in a one touch. If you have the card then you can do what you want with your card.

[sjw241]

I think that it lowers the value of the card but I would take it out and put it in a one touch. If you have the card then you can do what you want with your card.

I recently sold a Lidstrom Auto that was out of the original ITG sealed top loader. It went for $25 or so. I sold the same card, with the seal and in the original toploader a few months back for $12 and change.

I don't think it matters if it is in the sealed holder or not. The card is what people want, not the top loader and sticker.

[iidaemmi]

Dr. Price personally said that 'go on and broke them', and still we are talking about this 'problem'! So how about if we all just broke them.. then we don't need a talk again and again..

I have here http://s147.photobucket.com/albums/r291/iidaemmi/Gilmour%20Superlative/ almost 50 high ends superlative cards. All broken. Also have four 1/1 Superlative Gilmour cards and broken.

Harri

[stop__dreaming]

Anyone know which one-touches work best with the Stick Work cards?

[robcynd]

i view these as a generic... off brand kinda thing

they are nice, but not for me

[gomaz]

If PC, yes. If not PC, no. Simply because it leaves the decision up to the next owner.

[charvey9]

I brake out my Superlative cards so I can scan them and put them in new top loaders or one-touch holders and put them in my PC box.

The question has been asked many times over the past 5 years. Answer is still the same. They are your cards, do what you want. The stickers and top loaders were never meant to be a permanent home for the cards, just a way to protect them until they get pulled.

[Kehfee]

If PC, yes. If not PC, no. Simply because it leaves the decision up to the next owner.

That's what I did. All my pc superlatives are in one touches and the ones I got from breaks that are traders are in the original top loader.

Just busted out a Superlative Wendel Auto yesterday. :)