Interesting Idea

[Oaktownraiders84]

The guy who means the most to his team. COME ONE no brainer MICHAEL VICK. I hate vick and think he is a sorry QB but remember the year he broke his leg they did NOTHING won like 3 games then came back next year and was 1 game away from SB i think he is more a WR then a QB but if 1 guy in the leauge would hurt his team the most by being injured it is vick

[deansayso]

haha you guys arent thinking.....John Elway. Who did he have to work with besides in his two superbowl victories?

[corpsman312]

Ok this topic has obviously turned into a favoritism topic. The majority of people posting on this topic are seemingly picking their favorite player from their favorite team, or the best player who has ever played for that specific team. I dont think that was the idea behind this topic.

[DeWittFootball20]

LT hands down

[deansayso]

even without lt, they would still have star players that greatly contribute to a team...

[sHiNo]

Ok this topic has obviously turned into a favoritism topic. The majority of people posting on this topic are seemingly picking their favorite player from their favorite team, or the best player who has ever played for that specific team. I dont think that was the idea behind this topic.

Even if I like Urlacher that doesn't change the fact that he impacts the game like only a few other LBs can. I'm sorry you can't say that about Julius Jones, but that's the truth about Urlacher.

[corpsman312]

Even if I like Urlacher that doesn't change the fact that he impacts the game like only a few other LBs can. I'm sorry you can't say that about Julius Jones, but that's the truth about Urlacher.

Urlacher is good- not great, but good. What makes him great is his supporting cast. Without Urlacher the Bears would still have a very solid defense.

How many games has Urlacher won for his team this season?

[nflcardlover]

Im not trying to be favoritism but think about it....McNabb has never had a good wr on his team (unless you count t.o which I consider more of a problem than help) but he still puts up amazing numbers like 104 passer rating in 2004.

[BrewCrew06]

I'm going to throw a name out there, Brett Favre. What are people's thoughts on him? Look what he's done this year. He's playing behind a very very young offensive line, with 3 rookie's starting. Green and Driver have been playing better than expected. His string of consecutive games played is amazing, especially playing through some of hte injuries he's had in the past few years. I'm not playing favorite, I'm just throwing his name out there. He's a guy that plays the game the way it should be played, plays with more emotion than a lot of other players.

[eaglefan52081]

Donovan McNabb, went to 4 NFC Title Games and the Super Bowl practically by himself.