All Time Greats Survivor: Second Base

[cardinalfan15]

Roberto Alomar...treat umpires with some respect!

[Bonds_25]

Roberto Alomar, doesn't respect the game. Jeff Kent may even be a better candidate then him.

[leftyshan]

Robbie's got to go!!! You can't even mention him with the rest of the guys on that list.

[NolanRyanExpress]

Ryne Sandberg: 2386H, 403-2B, 76-3B, 282HR, 1318R, 1061RBI, 344SB, .285BA, .344OB, .452SLG,

[pwaldo]

Sandberg-2
Frisch-1
Alomar-9
Carew-1
Morgan-1

I went with Alomar and with 9 votes he is gone.

These are the guys that are left:

Jackie Robinson: 1518H, 273-2B, 54-3B, 137HR, 947R, 734RBI, 197SB, .311BA, .409OB, .474SLG

Rogers Hornsby: 2930H, 541-2B, 169-3B, 301HR, 1579R, 1584RBI, 135SB, .358BA, .434OB, .577SLG

Rod Carew: 3053H, 445-2B, 112-3B, 92HR, 1424R, 1015RBI, 353SB, .328BA, .393OB, .429SLG

Nap Lajoie: 3242H, 657-2B, 163-3B, 83HR, 1502R, 1599RBI, 380SB, .338BA, .380OB, .467SLG

Eddie Collins: 3315H, 438-2B, 187-3B, 47HR, 1821R, 1300RBI, 744SB, .333BA, .424OB, .429SLG

Joe Morgan: 2517H, 449-2B, 96-3B, 268HR, 1650R, 1133RBI, 689SB, .271BA, .382OB, .427SLG

Frankie Frisch:2880H, 466-2B, 138-3B, 105HR, 1532R, 1244RBI, 419SB, .316BA, .369OB, .432SLG

Charlie Gehringer:2839H, 574-2B,146-3B, 184HR, 1774R, 1427RBI, 181SB, .320BA, .404OB, .480SLG

Ryne Sandberg: 2386H, 403-2B, 76-3B, 282HR, 1318R, 1061RBI, 344SB, .285BA, .344OB, .452SLG

[Molina00]

I see you decided to pick up where I left off. I would have kept it going but I didn't have the time.

Anyway, I vote Sandberg.
He was good but I wouldn't say he was great.

[Bonds_25]

I will go with Sandberg as well - not quite in the class of the others.

[cardinalfan15]

Ryno- numbers don't quite compare (though he has great HR numbers).

[Molina00]

Originally posted by sealedpwr
Roberto Alomar,

Alomar was eliminated in the first round.

[pwaldo]

Guys Alomar was already eliminated.