Go Shaun Hill!!!!

[BU54CB]

You're still ignoring my point about the 49ers fans and Scot McCloughen always want Alex Smith to be the man of the 49ers' team. It is not from my view or opinion, but that is what actually happened. Your illogical opinion is too bias and lack strong evidence. I enjoy the fact that you're still underestimating Shaun Hill.

So what you're telling us is that the 49ers fans are determining who the starting QB is? Talk about an illogical opinion lacking strong evidence. GM's nor teams do not listen to fans when making roster decisions period.

[pghin08]

That quote already answered to your question.

And I'm telling you that it's a crap excuse. Teams want to win games. If you have someone that you feel could be a franchise QB, you don't just trade him away because some fans want to see the other QB. In fact, I find it hard to believe there were a massive amount of fans who wanted to see Alex Smith. I'm not going to act like some 49er fan expert, but if that's true, then I don't understand that logic. Smith had toiled for 5 seasons (at that point), and hadn't showed much. Why the push for him?

[PatrickWillis52]

And I'm telling you that it's a crap excuse. Teams want to win games. If you have someone that you feel could be a franchise QB, you don't just trade him away because some fans want to see the other QB. In fact, I find it hard to believe there were a massive amount of fans who wanted to see Alex Smith. I'm not going to act like some 49er fan expert, but if that's true, then I don't understand that logic. Smith had toiled for 5 seasons (at that point), and hadn't showed much. Why the push for him?

That is not a crap excuse. That's the fact, even Coach Singletary state that was the reason why Shaun Hill traded away. Your second sentence is true about Alex Smith, but we are talking about the 2010's offseason and before that. Right now, many 49ers fans regretted about chanting for Alex Smith after Shaun Hill had his first bad game at playing home. Like I said, the 49ers fans and Scot McCloughen still have faiths in Alex Smith and give him infinite chances.

Let me remind you one more time, that paragraph above this sentence is not my opinion. This is what actually happened, a fact. There is no logic behind the fact, when something is ignorant.

Why do you think Scot McCloughen got fired after trading Shaun Hill away? After he lost his GM job, he joined Seahawks as a scout for college players. There's a conspiracy theory about this in the 49ers forums.

[PatrickWillis52]

So what you're telling us is that the 49ers fans are determining who the starting QB is? Talk about an illogical opinion lacking strong evidence. GM's nor teams do not listen to fans when making roster decisions period.

That's what happened in the game against the Falcons in the first half. There was the loudest boo and so many upset chantings for Alex Smith. After halftime, Alex Smith started the game.

That game was only FIRST GAME SHAUN HILL GOT A BAD GAME AT HOME. He's been undefeated playing at 49ers home for a very long time, until that game against the Falcons. The 49ers gave up on Hill too early, due to the 49ers fans and GM being lovers to Alex Smith.

Do you know that this same GM got fired in the offseason?

Every question you guys asked where my answers are already posted somewhere. I'd suggest you guys need to improve your reading skills, there's nothing wrong with attending a community college for Reading 101.

[megabyterex]

I guess it comes down to watching the games..Living in Michigan, while not a Lions fan, its the only 1PM games they show, so i'm kinda stuck until the 4PM games start. Hill dumps the ball off unless its a pass to Calvin..honestly thats what happens..he manages the game OK, but thats about it, and the Lions arent exactally in a position with the defense they have, to have a QB who manages games..They need a game changer. Stafford might not be that guy, but i'm sure they'll figure that out once he can stay on the field and be healthy

Although I will say, Shaun Hill has been helping me win a pool i'm in, i give him that much.

True, i don't watch other games other then what my cable provides and i can only analyze by stats.

[Hoosfn]

Only thing you keep over looking from the post were several people called you on was the 10 teams he could be starting for right now. I can give you 2 to help you get started Browns (cause everyone is hurt and McCoy isn't ready) and the Panthers( again Clausen isn't ready) but would never be a long term guy.

It is Stafford's job and will be for a long time.

[pghin08]

That is not a crap excuse. That's the fact, even Coach Singletary state that was the reason why Shaun Hill traded away. Your second sentence is true about Alex Smith, but we are talking about the 2010's offseason and before that. Right now, many 49ers fans regretted about chanting for Alex Smith after Shaun Hill had his first bad game at playing home. Like I said, the 49ers fans and Scot McCloughen still have faiths in Alex Smith and give him infinite chances.

Let me remind you one more time, that paragraph above this sentence is not my opinion. This is what actually happened, a fact. There is no logic behind the fact, when something is ignorant.

Why do you think Scot McCloughen got fired after trading Shaun Hill away? After he lost his GM job, he joined Seahawks as a scout for college players. There's a conspiracy theory about this in the 49ers forums.

So am I correct in thinking that you believe that there's a conspiracy against Shaun Hill? That he was doomed with the Niners from the start?

[BU54CB]

That's what happened in the game against the Falcons in the first half. There was the loudest boo and so many upset chantings for Alex Smith. After halftime, Alex Smith started the game.

That game was only FIRST GAME SHAUN HILL GOT A BAD GAME AT HOME. He's been undefeated playing at 49ers home for a very long time, until that game against the Falcons. The 49ers gave up on Hill too early, due to the 49ers fans and GM being lovers to Alex Smith.

Do you know that this same GM got fired in the offseason?

Every question you guys asked where my answers are already posted somewhere. I'd suggest you guys need to improve your reading skills, there's nothing wrong with attending a community college for Reading 101.

I know the GM got fired, because he wasn't doing a good job. The fans do not determine who the QB is on any team, you'd be foolish to think otherwise.

Your answers aren't already posted somewhere, I still don't see you listing the 10 teams Shaun Hill could be starting for right now, where is that answer ?

Before you say people need to improve their reading skills, you'd best look in the mirror. You're having trouble putting together simple sentences that make sense, so I'd stop while you're ahead.

[PatrickWillis52]

I know the GM got fired, because he wasn't doing a good job. The fans do not determine who the QB is on any team, you'd be foolish to think otherwise.

Your answers aren't already posted somewhere, I still don't see you listing the 10 teams Shaun Hill could be starting for right now, where is that answer ?

Before you say people need to improve their reading skills, you'd best look in the mirror. You're having trouble putting together simple sentences that make sense, so I'd stop while you're ahead.

I already explained about the game and the fans demanding Alex Smith. It's not the fans, but the GM Scot McCloughen who made the decision to keep Alex Smith as a starting quarterback. The fans still support Alex Smith, so they continue buying his jerseys and going to the games. If GM Scot McCloughen isn't being personal with Alex Smith and doesn't care about the fans, then the 49ers would have given up on Alex Smith in 2-3 years ago. Shaun Hill should be the starting QB this season.

However, it didn't happen because Scot McCloughen traded Shaun Hill away before he lost his job. I am sure Scot knew that Shaun Hill will be the starting QB if he didn't trade away before he got demoted.

I can provide you a thread where the 49ers fans regret about Shaun Hill and wish the 49ers didn't make the trade.

For reading vs writing classes, that's a huge different. Reading course at a community college teaches you the strategy to improve your reading skill. It also teaches you how to obtain the information and look up the passage to see if it already answers your questions. Writing a sentence is completely different story.

[BU54CB]

I already explained about the game and the fans demanding Alex Smith. It's not the fans, but the GM Scot McCloughen who made the decision to keep Alex Smith as a starting quarterback. The fans still support Alex Smith, so they continue buying his jerseys and going to the games. If GM Scot McCloughen isn't being personal with Alex Smith and doesn't care about the fans, then the 49ers would have given up on Alex Smith in 2-3 years ago. Shaun Hill should be the starting QB this season.

However, it didn't happen because Scot McCloughen traded Shaun Hill away before he lost his job. I am sure Scot knew that Shaun Hill will be the starting QB if he didn't trade away before he got demoted.

I can provide you a thread where the 49ers fans regret about Shaun Hill and wish the 49ers didn't make the trade.

For reading vs writing classes, that's a huge different. Reading course at a community college teaches you the strategy to improve your reading skill. It also teaches you how to obtain the information and look up the passage to see if it already answers your questions. Writing a sentence is completely different story.

Alex Smith has a starting job for 3 reasons, he has talent, he was the #1 overall draft pick in 2005, and a 6 year $49.5 million dollar contract with $24 million in guaranteed money. Those 3 reasons have nothing to do with the fans or being "personal" with the fans.

Whether you realize it or not, Shaun Hill is not as talented as other QB's in the league, otherwise teams would be desperately trying to get him to play as a starter on their team.

You still haven't addressed some of the questions directed at you, so there is no reading problem or inability to look up passages on our end. As I indicated before, perhaps you should look in the mirror before pointing the finger at others.