Carmelo Anthony...Superstar?

[gladdyontherise]

Apparantly Carmelo Anthony is no superstar i was told..

So vote yes or no, and please explain, weather you all vote yes or no, i still think he is.

Averages for his short career 24.1 points per game, 6.1 rebounds 3.1 assists, 1.1 steals, shoots 46% from the field...

[aw00d05]

He is...Just been hurt this year...

[nadeau01_johnson48]

Absolutely he is. The only reason people will say he isn't is because he isn't doing the things that LeBron and Wade are doing.

[NyEverything]

without a doubt he is ..probably the second best offensive player in the league behind kobe ..he has no weakness in his offensive game ..he could play defense a lil betta..but its cause of his rookie class that they compare him with ..wade already won a ring and lebron has been in the finals already ..thas the only reason there would be doubts..

[kobe080]

I think there is a clear distinction between superstar and a star....

or at least in my mind.

Superstar = capable of leading his team to conference finals at least.

star= capable of leading his team to the playoffs.

I regard Tmac, and Melo as a star, not a superstar.

He is a really good player but thus far, not capable of leading his team to a competitor.

Melo is a class under Lebron, Kobe, Duncan and KG in my opinion.

[aw00d05]

I think there is a clear distinction between superstar and a star....

or at least in my mind.

Superstar = capable of leading his team to conference finals at least.

star= capable of leading his team to the playoffs.

I regard Tmac, and Melo as a star, not a superstar.

He is a really good player but thus far, not capable of leading his team to a competitor.

Melo is a class under Lebron, Kobe, Duncan and KG in my opinion.

All the guys you listed are top 50 players of all time...Plus his whole career besides this year has been in the impossible Western Confrence where you had to have teammates to make the confrence finals.

[tmac]

i think he is and he is still improving on his game

the only thing thats been holding him back is his injury

[gladdyontherise]

Well i was told Melo was no superstar and someone said it was unfair i wouldnt trade my Melo GU's/Shaq GU bv for bv for KG refractors/parallels/inserts

yea right, i'm not stupid, no one would do that kind of trade, he insisted Melo is no superstar

[aw00d05]

Well i was told Melo was no superstar and someone said it was unfair i wouldnt trade my Melo GU's/Shaq GU bv for bv for KG refractors/parallels/inserts

yea right, i'm not stupid, no one would do that kind of trade, he insisted Melo is no superstar

[gladdyontherise]

I think there is a clear distinction between superstar and a star....

or at least in my mind.

Superstar = capable of leading his team to conference finals at least.

star= capable of leading his team to the playoffs.

I regard Tmac, and Melo as a star, not a superstar.

He is a really good player but thus far, not capable of leading his team to a competitor.

Melo is a class under Lebron, Kobe, Duncan and KG in my opinion.

i know what your saying but put the Cavs in the West, they wouldnt make it to the Western finals or Finals in general going through the west a much tougher confrence than the East